Amendment 58, after paragraph 4 · Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield · Vote

Result

The vote as recorded by name.

Rejected · 14 % of the votes cast were for.

Groups

Members' votes, each counted in the group they belonged to on the day. **No vote**: in office that day, no position recorded. **Majority line**: the most common position. **Clear line**: a position with at least two thirds of the group's votes (at least 10 members voting), otherwise Divided. **Cohesion**: Agreement Index, 0 = evenly split, 1 = all voted the same (method).
Group	For	Against	Abst.	No vote	Majority line	Clear line	Cohesion
The Left	For 0	Against 35	Abst. 5	No vote 4 of 44	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.81
Greens	For 2	Against 49	Abst. 0	No vote 2 of 53	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.94
S&D	For 4	Against 119	Abst. 0	No vote 12 of 135	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.95
Renew	For 4	Against 71	Abst. 0	No vote 3 of 78	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.92
EPP	For 13	Against 158	Abst. 2	No vote 11 of 184	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.87
ECR	For 43	Against 2	Abst. 28	No vote 11 of 84	Majority line For	Clear line Divided	Cohesion 0.38
Patriots	For 21	Against 0	Abst. 44	No vote 19 of 84	Majority line Abstained	Clear line Abstained	Cohesion 0.52
ESN	For 3	Against 4	Abst. 20	No vote 0 of 27	Majority line Abstained	Clear line Abstained	Cohesion 0.61
No group	For 3	Against 20	Abst. 4	No vote 1 of 28	Majority line —	Clear line No line	Cohesion —

Countries × groups

How each country’s members of each group voted.

Each cell: members of that country in that group who voted for – against – abstained (group at the date of the vote). Shading: the share of the cell's votes that were for; the stronger the shading, the more for (scale below). — : no member voted.
Country	The Left	Greens	S&D	Renew	EPP	ECR	Patriots	ESN	No group
Austria	no member voted	0–2–0	0–5–0	0–2–0	0–5–0	no member voted	1–0–5	no member voted	no member voted
Belgium	0–2–0	0–2–0	0–4–0	0–5–0	0–3–0	3–0–0	3–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Bulgaria	no member voted	no member voted	0–2–0	0–3–0	3–1–0	1–0–0	no member voted	0–3–0	no member voted
Cyprus	0–1–0	no member voted	0–1–0	no member voted	0–2–0	0–0–1	no member voted	no member voted	0–1–0
Czechia	no member voted	0–1–0	no member voted	no member voted	4–1–0	4–0–0	5–0–1	0–1–0	0–2–0
Germany	0–2–0	0–15–0	0–14–0	0–9–0	0–29–0	no member voted	no member voted	0–0–15	0–7–1
Denmark	0–1–0	0–2–0	0–2–0	0–4–0	0–1–1	1–0–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Estonia	no member voted	no member voted	0–2–0	0–2–0	0–2–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Spain	0–3–0	0–4–0	0–19–0	0–1–0	0–22–0	1–0–1	6–0–0	no member voted	0–0–1
Finland	0–0–3	0–1–0	0–2–0	0–3–0	0–4–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
France	0–7–0	0–5–0	0–12–0	0–13–0	1–3–1	0–0–4	0–0–28	1–0–0	0–1–0
Greece	0–3–0	no member voted	0–4–0	no member voted	0–7–0	0–2–0	1–0–0	no member voted	1–3–0
Croatia	no member voted	0–1–0	1–3–0	no member voted	0–6–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Hungary	no member voted	no member voted	0–1–0	no member voted	0–6–0	no member voted	no member voted	0–0–1	no member voted
Ireland	0–3–0	no member voted	0–1–0	0–4–0	0–3–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Italy	0–10–0	0–4–0	0–18–0	0–1–0	0–9–0	0–0–22	0–0–5	0–0–1	no member voted
Lithuania	no member voted	1–0–0	0–2–0	2–0–0	0–3–0	2–0–0	no member voted	0–0–1	no member voted
Luxembourg	no member voted	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–2–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	1–0–0
Latvia	no member voted	1–0–0	0–1–0	1–0–0	0–2–0	3–0–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Malta	no member voted	no member voted	0–3–0	no member voted	0–2–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Netherlands	0–1–0	0–6–0	0–4–0	0–7–0	0–4–0	3–0–0	0–0–5	no member voted	no member voted
Poland	no member voted	no member voted	3–0–0	1–0–0	1–21–0	15–0–0	2–0–0	2–0–0	0–0–1
Portugal	0–2–0	no member voted	0–5–0	0–2–0	0–7–0	no member voted	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Romania	no member voted	0–1–0	0–7–0	0–3–0	0–8–0	5–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	0–0–1
Sweden	0–0–2	0–3–0	0–5–0	0–3–0	1–4–0	3–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Slovenia	no member voted	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–2–0	2–1–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	1–0–0
Slovakia	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	0–6–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	0–0–2	0–6–0

Share for: 0–19 %20–39 %40–59 %60–79 %80–100 %

Renew members by country who voted for, against or abstained (group at the date of the vote).
Country	For	Against
Austria	0	2
Belgium	0	5
Bulgaria	0	3
Germany	0	9
Denmark	0	4
Estonia	0	2
Spain	0	1
Finland	0	3
France	0	13
Ireland	0	4
Italy	0	1
Lithuania	2	0
Luxembourg	0	1
Latvia	1	0
Netherlands	0	7
Poland	1	0
Portugal	0	2
Romania	0	3
Sweden	0	3
Slovenia	0	2
Slovakia	0	6

Members

Each member’s recorded position, in the group they sat in that day. Filter by country, group, position or name.

Show all 654 members

No vote recorded, 63

Members in office that day without a recorded position. No vote recorded is not the same as absent: leave, illness or chairing the sitting look the same.

Show the 63 members

Name · group that day · country

Adina VĂLEAN group that day: EPP · Romania
Aldo PATRICIELLO group that day: Patriots · Italy
Ana Catarina MENDES group that day: S&D · Portugal
András GYÜRK group that day: Patriots · Hungary
András LÁSZLÓ group that day: Patriots · Hungary
André FRANQUEIRA RODRIGUES group that day: S&D · Portugal
Andrey NOVAKOV group that day: EPP · Bulgaria
Annamária VICSEK group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Anthony SMITH group that day: The Left · France
António TÂNGER CORRÊA group that day: Patriots · Portugal
Barry COWEN group that day: Renew · Ireland
Borys BUDKA group that day: EPP · Poland
Bruno GONÇALVES group that day: S&D · Portugal
Christian DOLESCHAL group that day: EPP · Germany
Christian EHLER group that day: EPP · Germany
Christophe BAY group that day: Patriots · France
Claudiu MANDA group that day: S&D · Romania
Csaba DÖMÖTÖR group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Cynthia NÍ MHURCHÚ group that day: Renew · Ireland
Dominik TARCZYŃSKI group that day: ECR · Poland
Elena YONCHEVA group that day: ECR · Bulgaria
Emil RADEV group that day: EPP · Bulgaria
Emma RAFOWICZ group that day: S&D · France
Enikő GYŐRI group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Ewa ZAJĄCZKOWSKA-HERNIK group that day: Patriots · Poland
Gabriela FIREA group that day: S&D · Romania
Gabriella GERZSENYI group that day: EPP · Hungary
Gheorghe CÂRCIU group that day: S&D · Romania
Giorgio GORI group that day: S&D · Italy
Giovanni CROSETTO group that day: ECR · Italy
Giuseppe MILAZZO group that day: ECR · Italy
György HÖLVÉNYI group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Isabella TOVAGLIERI group that day: Patriots · Italy
Ivaylo VALCHEV group that day: ECR · Bulgaria
Jaak MADISON group that day: ECR · Estonia
Jacek OZDOBA group that day: ECR · Poland
Jaroslav KNOT group that day: Patriots · Czechia
Javi LÓPEZ group that day: S&D · Spain
Kinga GÁL group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN group that day: Greens · Denmark
Klára DOBREV group that day: S&D · Hungary
Klara DOSTALOVA group that day: Patriots · Czechia
Luis-Vicențiu LAZARUS group that day: No group · Romania
Maria WALSH group that day: EPP · Ireland
Marianne VIND group that day: S&D · Denmark
Matthieu VALET group that day: Patriots · France
Michał DWORCZYK group that day: ECR · Poland
Mieke ANDRIESE group that day: Patriots · Netherlands
Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA group that day: EPP · Romania
Özlem DEMIREL group that day: The Left · Germany
Pernando BARRENA ARZA group that day: The Left · Spain
Pina PICIERNO group that day: Renew · Italy
Piotr MÜLLER group that day: ECR · Poland
Rima HASSAN group that day: The Left · France
Roberta METSOLA group that day: EPP · Malta
Romana TOMC group that day: EPP · Slovenia
Şerban Dimitrie STURDZA group that day: ECR · Romania
Tamás DEUTSCH group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Victor NEGRESCU group that day: S&D · Romania
Viktória FERENC group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Ville NIINISTÖ group that day: Greens · Finland
Waldemar BUDA group that day: ECR · Poland

Similar votes

Roll calls that split the chamber the most similarly: r is the correlation of members’ positions, over the members who voted in both. Other votes on the same decision are left out.

**Result**: for–against–abstained. **For**: share of the votes cast. **Requested by**: the groups that asked for a roll call.
Date	Vote	Kind	Result	For	Requested by	r · shared
23 Jan 2025	Amendment 4, adding text after paragraph 8 Situation in Venezuela following the usurpation of the presidency on 10 January 2025	Amendment	134 for, 283 against, 27 abstained Rejected	For 30 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.83 408 voters
23 Jan 2025	Amendment 2, adding text after paragraph 1 Situation in Venezuela following the usurpation of the presidency on 10 January 2025	Amendment	148 for, 285 against, 23 abstained Rejected	For 32 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.81 421 voters
17 Sept 2026	Amendment 5 to paragraph 8 Political prisoners in Cuba, in particular the case of Félix Navarro and his daughter Saylí Navarro	Amendment	145 for, 417 against, 24 abstained Rejected	For 25 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.79 564 voters

Show 7 more

**Result**: for–against–abstained. **For**: share of the votes cast. **Requested by**: the groups that asked for a roll call.
Date	Vote	Kind	Result	For	Requested by	r · shared
23 Jan 2025	Amendment 3, adding text after paragraph 2 Situation in Venezuela following the usurpation of the presidency on 10 January 2025	Amendment	148 for, 294 against, 12 abstained Rejected	For 33 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.79 417 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 164 to paragraph 74 Implementation of the common foreign and security policy – annual report 2024	Amendment	194 for, 472 against, 11 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.77 609 voters
17 Sept 2026	Amendment 76, adding text after paragraph 7 The recent hybrid attacks and instrumentalisation of migrants in Ceuta and the need for a coordinated response to protect EU’s external borders	Amendment	177 for, 418 against, 13 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by ECR	r · shared0.77 575 voters
21 May 2026	Amendment 3 to paragraph 4 Repression and execution of protesters, dissidents, political prisoners and religious minorities in Iran	Amendment	178 for, 379 against, 12 abstained Rejected	For 31 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.77 530 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 145 to paragraph 4, indent 7 Implementation of the common foreign and security policy – annual report 2024	Amendment	192 for, 448 against, 11 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.77 587 voters
21 May 2026	Amendment 7 to paragraph 12 Repression and execution of protesters, dissidents, political prisoners and religious minorities in Iran	Amendment	165 for, 386 against, 18 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.77 530 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 154 to paragraph 28 Implementation of the common foreign and security policy – annual report 2024	Amendment	185 for, 445 against, 20 abstained Rejected	For 28 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.76 585 voters

How similarity is measured

Compare with another vote

Groups’ lines side by side, and the members who switched between the two votes.

Another vote on this decision

Connections

This vote’s decision, the other votes on it, and related votes.

Show 11 connections: The decision · Other votes on this decision

The decision

Decision Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield Resolution · report by Tomas Tobé 15 Sept 2026 Adopted

Other votes on this decision

Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 27 to paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 2, adding text after paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 28, adding text after paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 29, adding text after paragraph 2 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 88, adding text after paragraph 2 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 30, adding text after paragraph 3 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 60, adding text after paragraph 4 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 57, adding text after paragraph 5 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Amendment 15, adding text after paragraph 6 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026
Vote Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield — Paragraph 9 — part 1 Roll-call vote · 15 Sept 2026 15 Sept 2026

See all

Sources & citation

Where the facts on this page come from, and how to cite it.

Permalink: https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2026-09-15/196320
Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 15 September 2026 (European Parliament)
Results of votes, sitting of 15 September 2026 (European Parliament)
Data source: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2026-09-15
Licensed CC BY 4.0.
Retrieved: 25 September 2026

Cite as

European Parliament (2026). “Amendment 58, after paragraph 4 — Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield”. Vote, 15 September 2026. votingId 196320, reference 2025/2069(INI). EU Parl Watch Research. https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2026-09-15/196320 (retrieved 25 September 2026). Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 15 September 2026 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2026-09-15-RCV_EN.html; Results of votes, sitting of 15 September 2026 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2026-09-15-VOT_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2026-09-15, https://data.europarl.europa.eu/api/v2/meetings/MTG-PL-2026-09-15/vote-results?format=application%2Fld%2Bjson (CC BY 4.0).

BibTeX

@misc{epw-vote-2026-09-15-196320,
  author = {{European Parliament}},
  title = {{Amendment 58, after paragraph 4 — Findings and recommendations of the Special Committee on the European Democracy Shield}},
  year = {2026},
  date = {2026-09-15},
  howpublished = {\url{https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2026-09-15/196320}},
  url = {https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2026-09-15/196320},
  urldate = {2026-09-25},
  publisher = {EU Parl Watch Research},
  note = {Vote. votingId 196320, reference 2025/2069(INI). Official source: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2026-09-15-RCV\_EN.html, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2026-09-15-VOT\_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2026-09-15 (CC BY 4.0)}
}