Vote · Roll call

Amendment 23 — part 2, after paragraph 43

General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections

Vote: Amendment 23 — part 2, after paragraph 43
Decision: No. 4 of the sitting of 23 Oct 2024
Result: 180 for · 452 against · 15 abstained Rejected · roll call
Date: 23 October 2024, 13:28

More facts (6)

Position: vote 51 of 152 on the decision
Requested by: roll call: Patriots, EPP · split vote: EPP
Official label: A10–0008/2024 – Victor Negrescu, Niclas Herbst – After § 43 – Am 23/2
Text: Report A-10-2024-0008
Dossier: 2024/0176(BUD)
Vote id: 170105

Position: vote 51 of 152 on the decision
Requested by: roll call: Patriots, EPP · split vote: EPP
Official label: A10–0008/2024 – Victor Negrescu, Niclas Herbst – After § 43 – Am 23/2
Text: Report A-10-2024-0008
Dossier: 2024/0176(BUD)
Vote id: 170105

Cite this page

The members file includes members in office who did not vote.

Roll-call results (EP)

Link to this page

Result

The vote as recorded by name.

Rejected · 28 % of the votes cast were for.

Part voted on: “those words”

Groups

Members' votes, each counted in the group they belonged to on the day. **No vote**: in office that day, no position recorded. **Majority line**: the most common position. **Clear line**: a position with at least two thirds of the group's votes (at least 10 members voting), otherwise Divided. **Cohesion**: Agreement Index, 0 = evenly split, 1 = all voted the same (method).
Group	For	Against	Abst.	No vote	Majority line	Clear line	Cohesion
The Left	For 1	Against 43	Abst. 0	No vote 2 of 46	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.97
Greens	For 0	Against 49	Abst. 0	No vote 4 of 53	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 1.00
S&D	For 0	Against 122	Abst. 1	No vote 13 of 136	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.99
Renew	For 0	Against 69	Abst. 0	No vote 8 of 77	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 1.00
EPP	For 4	Against 162	Abst. 3	No vote 19 of 188	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.94
ECR	For 57	Against 4	Abst. 8	No vote 9 of 78	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 0.74
Patriots	For 79	Against 0	Abst. 0	No vote 7 of 86	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 1.00
ESN	For 20	Against 0	Abst. 0	No vote 5 of 25	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 1.00
No group	For 19	Against 3	Abst. 3	No vote 5 of 30	Majority line —	Clear line No line	Cohesion —

Members who changed group are counted in the group of the day: Branko GRIMS changed group, Diego SOLIER changed group, Elena YONCHEVA changed group, Elisabetta GUALMINI changed group, Ewa ZAJĄCZKOWSKA-HERNIK changed group, Fernand KARTHEISER changed group, Jessika VAN LEEUWEN changed group, Laurent CASTILLO changed group, Lukas SIEPER changed group, Malika SOREL changed group, Milan MAZUREK changed group, Nikola BARTŮŠEK changed group, Nikolas FARANTOURIS changed group, Nora JUNCO GARCÍA changed group, Pina PICIERNO changed group, Roberto VANNACCI changed group, Sander SMIT changed group, Taner KABILOV changed group.

Countries × groups

How each country’s members of each group voted.

Each cell: members of that country in that group who voted for – against – abstained (group at the date of the vote). Shading: the share of the cell's votes that were for; the stronger the shading, the more for (scale below). — : no member voted.
Country	The Left	Greens	S&D	Renew	EPP	ECR	Patriots	ESN	No group
Austria	no member voted	0–2–0	0–4–0	0–2–0	0–4–0	no member voted	5–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Belgium	0–2–0	0–2–0	0–4–0	0–4–0	0–3–0	0–2–0	3–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Bulgaria	no member voted	no member voted	0–2–0	0–3–0	0–5–0	1–0–0	no member voted	3–0–0	no member voted
Cyprus	0–1–0	no member voted	0–1–0	no member voted	0–2–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Czechia	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	0–4–0	1–0–2	8–0–0	1–0–0	2–0–0
Germany	0–4–0	0–15–0	0–12–0	0–7–0	0–29–0	no member voted	no member voted	10–0–0	5–1–0
Denmark	0–1–0	0–3–0	0–2–0	0–3–0	0–2–0	0–1–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Estonia	no member voted	no member voted	0–1–0	0–2–0	0–2–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Spain	0–4–0	0–4–0	0–17–0	0–1–0	0–18–1	no member voted	6–0–0	no member voted	3–0–0
Finland	0–3–0	0–2–0	0–2–0	0–3–0	0–4–0	0–1–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
France	0–9–0	0–5–0	0–12–0	0–12–0	0–4–1	2–0–0	29–0–0	1–0–0	no member voted
Greece	0–4–0	no member voted	0–3–0	no member voted	0–7–0	2–0–0	1–0–0	no member voted	1–2–1
Croatia	no member voted	0–1–0	0–4–0	no member voted	0–4–1	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Hungary	no member voted	no member voted	0–2–0	no member voted	0–6–0	no member voted	10–0–0	1–0–0	no member voted
Ireland	0–2–0	no member voted	0–1–0	0–6–0	0–4–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Italy	0–9–0	0–3–0	0–20–1	no member voted	0–9–0	22–0–0	7–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Lithuania	no member voted	no member voted	0–2–0	0–2–0	0–3–0	2–0–0	no member voted	1–0–0	no member voted
Luxembourg	no member voted	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–2–0	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Latvia	no member voted	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–2–0	0–0–3	1–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Malta	no member voted	no member voted	0–3–0	no member voted	0–2–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Netherlands	0–1–0	0–6–0	0–3–0	0–6–0	0–6–0	1–0–0	5–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Poland	no member voted	no member voted	0–3–0	0–1–0	0–22–0	19–0–0	2–0–0	2–0–0	0–0–1
Portugal	1–1–0	no member voted	0–8–0	0–2–0	0–6–0	no member voted	2–0–0	no member voted	no member voted
Romania	no member voted	no member voted	0–8–0	0–2–0	0–5–0	3–0–0	no member voted	no member voted	1–0–1
Sweden	0–2–0	0–3–0	0–5–0	0–3–0	0–5–0	0–0–3	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Slovenia	no member voted	0–1–0	0–1–0	0–2–0	4–1–0	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted
Slovakia	no member voted	no member voted	no member voted	0–6–0	0–1–0	no member voted	no member voted	1–0–0	7–0–0

Share for: 0–19 %20–39 %40–59 %60–79 %80–100 %

Renew members by country who voted for, against or abstained (group at the date of the vote).
Country	For	Against	Abst.	Bar
Austria	0	2	0
Belgium	0	4	0
Bulgaria	0	3	0
Germany	0	7	0
Denmark	0	3	0
Estonia	0	2	0
Spain	0	1	0
Finland	0	3	0
France	0	12	0
Ireland	0	6	0
Lithuania	0	2	0
Luxembourg	0	1	0
Latvia	0	1	0
Netherlands	0	6	0
Poland	0	1	0
Portugal	0	2	0
Romania	0	2	0
Sweden	0	3	0
Slovenia	0	2	0
Slovakia	0	6	0

Members

Each member’s recorded position, in the group they sat in that day. Filter by country, group, position or name.

Show all 647 members

No vote recorded, 72

Members in office that day without a recorded position. No vote recorded is not the same as absent: leave, illness or chairing the sitting look the same.

Show the 72 members

Name · group that day · country

Adrian-George AXINIA group that day: ECR · Romania
Aldo PATRICIELLO group that day: Patriots · Italy
Alexandra MEHNERT group that day: EPP · Germany
Alicia HOMS GINEL group that day: S&D · Spain
Anders VISTISEN group that day: Patriots · Denmark
Andreas GLÜCK group that day: Renew · Germany
Andreas SCHIEDER group that day: S&D · Austria
Antonella SBERNA group that day: ECR · Italy
Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE group that day: EPP · Spain
Auke ZIJLSTRA group that day: Patriots · Netherlands
Aurore LALUCQ group that day: S&D · France
Bart GROOTHUIS group that day: Renew · Netherlands
Christian DOLESCHAL group that day: EPP · Germany
Claudiu MANDA group that day: S&D · Romania
Claudiu-Richard TÂRZIU group that day: ECR · Romania
Cristian TERHEŞ group that day: ECR · Romania
Cristina GUARDA group that day: Greens · Italy
Dan NICA group that day: S&D · Romania
Dan-Ştefan MOTREANU group that day: EPP · Romania
Daniel BUDA group that day: EPP · Romania
Enikő GYŐRI group that day: Patriots · Hungary
Eva MAYDELL group that day: EPP · Bulgaria
Fabio DE MASI group that day: No group · Germany
Fernando NAVARRETE ROJAS group that day: EPP · Spain
Fidias PANAYIOTOU group that day: No group · Cyprus
Gerald HAUSER group that day: Patriots · Austria
Guillaume PELTIER group that day: ECR · France
Hans NEUHOFF group that day: ESN · Germany
Ilhan KYUCHYUK group that day: Renew · Bulgaria
Ioan-Rareş BOGDAN group that day: EPP · Romania
Iuliu WINKLER group that day: EPP · Romania
Johan VAN OVERTVELDT group that day: ECR · Belgium
Jonás FERNÁNDEZ group that day: S&D · Spain
Karlo RESSLER group that day: EPP · Croatia
Katarina BARLEY group that day: S&D · Germany
Luděk NIEDERMAYER group that day: EPP · Czechia
Luke Ming FLANAGAN group that day: The Left · Ireland
Marianne VIND group that day: S&D · Denmark
Marina KALJURAND group that day: S&D · Estonia
Mario FURORE group that day: The Left · Italy
Mario MANTOVANI group that day: ECR · Italy
Markéta GREGOROVÁ group that day: Greens · Czechia
Markus BUCHHEIT group that day: ESN · Germany
Maximilian KRAH group that day: No group · Germany
Michał DWORCZYK group that day: ECR · Poland
Michał WAWRYKIEWICZ group that day: EPP · Poland
Mihai TUDOSE group that day: S&D · Romania
Mohammed CHAHIM group that day: S&D · Netherlands
Morten LØKKEGAARD group that day: Renew · Denmark
Nadine MORANO group that day: EPP · France
Nathalie LOISEAU group that day: Renew · France
Nicolae ȘTEFĂNUȚĂ group that day: Greens · Romania
Nicolas BAY group that day: ECR · France
Nikola MINCHEV group that day: Renew · Bulgaria
Ondřej KOVAŘÍK group that day: Patriots · Czechia
Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA group that day: EPP · Spain
Paulo DO NASCIMENTO CABRAL group that day: EPP · Portugal
Péter MAGYAR group that day: EPP · Hungary
Petr BYSTRON group that day: ESN · Germany
Pierre PIMPIE group that day: Patriots · France
Reinhold LOPATKA group that day: EPP · Austria
Roberta METSOLA group that day: EPP · Malta
Ruth FIRMENICH group that day: No group · Germany
Sandra GÓMEZ LÓPEZ group that day: S&D · Spain
Sibylle BERG group that day: No group · Germany
Siegbert Frank DROESE group that day: ESN · Germany
Stanisław TYSZKA group that day: ESN · Poland
Udo BULLMANN group that day: S&D · Germany
Virgil-Daniel POPESCU group that day: EPP · Romania
Virginijus SINKEVIČIUS group that day: Greens · Lithuania
Vlad VASILE-VOICULESCU group that day: Renew · Romania
Yvan VEROUGSTRAETE group that day: Renew · Belgium

Similar votes

Roll calls that split the chamber the most similarly: r is the correlation of members’ positions, over the members who voted in both. Other votes on the same decision are left out.

**Result**: for–against–abstained. **For**: share of the votes cast. **Requested by**: the groups that asked for a roll call.
Date	Vote	Kind	Result	For	Requested by	r · shared
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 69, adding text after paragraph 26 Guidelines for the 2026 budget – Section III	Amendment	193 for, 472 against, 8 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.98 602 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 51, adding text after paragraph 4 Guidelines for the 2026 budget – Section III	Amendment	193 for, 464 against, 7 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.97 595 voters
11 Mar 2025	Amendment 1, adding text after paragraph 4 Assessment of the implementation of Horizon Europe in view of its interim evaluation and recommendations for the 10th Research Framework Programme	Amendment	190 for, 469 against, 13 abstained Rejected	For 28 %	Requested by Members	r · shared0.97 607 voters

Show 7 more

**Result**: for–against–abstained. **For**: share of the votes cast. **Requested by**: the groups that asked for a roll call.
Date	Vote	Kind	Result	For	Requested by	r · shared
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 62, adding text after paragraph 19 Guidelines for the 2026 budget – Section III	Amendment	191 for, 463 against, 5 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.97 592 voters
25 Nov 2025	Amendment 9 to paragraph 2 Existence of a clear risk of a serious breach by Hungary of the values on which the Union is founded	Amendment	184 for, 450 against, 10 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by ESN	r · shared0.97 576 voters
25 Nov 2025	Amendment 8, adding text after paragraph 1 Existence of a clear risk of a serious breach by Hungary of the values on which the Union is founded	Amendment	186 for, 447 against, 11 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by ESN	r · shared0.97 575 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 68, adding text after paragraph 26 Guidelines for the 2026 budget – Section III	Amendment	186 for, 484 against, 4 abstained Rejected	For 28 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.96 604 voters
18 Jun 2025	Amendment 14, adding text after paragraph 70 The Commission’s 2024 Rule of Law report	Amendment	185 for, 447 against, 18 abstained Rejected	For 28 %	Requested by S&D, Members	r · shared0.96 584 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 19 to paragraph 54 Human rights and democracy in the world and the European Union’s policy on the matter – annual report 2024	Amendment	193 for, 462 against, 7 abstained Rejected	For 29 %	Requested by ESN	r · shared0.96 594 voters
2 Apr 2025	Amendment 76, adding text after paragraph 42 Guidelines for the 2026 budget – Section III	Amendment	181 for, 477 against, 17 abstained Rejected	For 27 %	Requested by Patriots	r · shared0.96 605 voters

How similarity is measured

Compare with another vote

Groups’ lines side by side, and the members who switched between the two votes.

Another vote on this decision

Connections

This vote’s decision, the other votes on it, and related votes.

Show 11 connections: The decision · Other votes on this decision

The decision

Decision General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections Budget decision · committee report 23 Oct 2024 Resolution rejected

Other votes on this decision

Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 3, adding text before paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 4, adding text before paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 5, adding text before paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 6, adding text before paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 7, adding text before paragraph 1 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 53, adding text after paragraph 4 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Paragraph 5 — part 2 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 54, adding text after paragraph 5 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Separate vote on paragraph 12 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024
Vote General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections — Amendment 18, adding text after paragraph 13 Roll-call vote · 23 Oct 2024 23 Oct 2024

See all

Sources & citation

Where the facts on this page come from, and how to cite it.

Permalink: https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2024-10-23/170105
Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 23 October 2024 (European Parliament)
Results of votes, sitting of 23 October 2024 (European Parliament)
Data source: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2024-10-23
Licensed CC BY 4.0.
Retrieved: 25 September 2026

Cite as

European Parliament (2024). “Amendment 23 — part 2, after paragraph 43 — General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections”. Vote, 23 October 2024. votingId 170105, reference 2024/0176(BUD). EU Parl Watch Research. https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2024-10-23/170105 (retrieved 25 September 2026). Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 23 October 2024 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2024-10-23-RCV_EN.html; Results of votes, sitting of 23 October 2024 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2024-10-23-VOT_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2024-10-23, https://data.europarl.europa.eu/api/v2/meetings/MTG-PL-2024-10-23/vote-results?format=application%2Fld%2Bjson (CC BY 4.0).

BibTeX

@misc{epw-vote-2024-10-23-170105,
  author = {{European Parliament}},
  title = {{Amendment 23 — part 2, after paragraph 43 — General budget of the European Union for the financial year 2025 – all sections}},
  year = {2024},
  date = {2024-10-23},
  howpublished = {\url{https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2024-10-23/170105}},
  url = {https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2024-10-23/170105},
  urldate = {2026-09-25},
  publisher = {EU Parl Watch Research},
  note = {Vote. votingId 170105, reference 2024/0176(BUD). Official source: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2024-10-23-RCV\_EN.html, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2024-10-23-VOT\_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2024-10-23 (CC BY 4.0)}
}