Skip to content

Decision · Objection under Rule 115(2) and (3) · implementing measure

Genetically modified maize DP910521

Effect
Objection passed
Result
477 for · 152 against · 20 abstained roll call
Date
12 February 2025, 12:08–12:09
Kind
Objection to a Commission measure
More facts (10)
Margin
by a large majority
Counts are for
the objection
Source
Motion for a resolution
Topics
Agriculture, food & fisheriesHealth Assigned by a model, not checked by hand.
Votes
4 votes · 3 roll calls · 2 amendments
Requested by
The Left (1 roll call) · Greens (1 roll call)
Final vote
171793
More

Result

The final vote and what it means for this kind of decision.

Final vote: 477 for, 152 against, 20 abstained (roll call).

Objection passed by a large majority.

The objection passed. For an implementing measure it is not legally binding: the Commission is asked to withdraw the measure but can still adopt it.

Before the final vote, MEPs decided on 2 amendments (1 adopted, 1 rejected) and 1 part of the text voted on separately (1 rejected).

Backed by The Left, Greens, S&D, Renew, ECR, Patriots and ESN; opposed by EPP.

Groups

Members' votes, each counted in the group they belonged to on the day. No vote: in office that day, no position recorded. Majority line: the most common position. Clear line: a position with at least two thirds of the group's votes (at least 10 members voting), otherwise Divided. Cohesion: Agreement Index, 0 = evenly split, 1 = all voted the same (method).
GroupForAgainstAbst.No voteMajority lineClear lineCohesionBar
The LeftFor 41Against 0Abst. 0No vote 5 of 46Majority line ForClear line For Cohesion 1.00
GreensFor 51Against 0Abst. 1No vote 1 of 53Majority line ForClear line For Cohesion 0.97
S&DFor 121Against 2Abst. 1No vote 12 of 136Majority line ForClear line For Cohesion 0.96
RenewFor 33Against 32Abst. 1No vote 9 of 75Majority line ForClear line Divided Cohesion 0.25
EPPFor 58Against 97Abst. 11No vote 22 of 188Majority line AgainstClear line Divided Cohesion 0.38
ECRFor 57Against 13Abst. 2No vote 8 of 80Majority line ForClear line For Cohesion 0.69
PatriotsFor 74Against 7Abst. 0No vote 5 of 86Majority line ForClear line For Cohesion 0.87
ESNFor 18Against 0Abst. 1No vote 7 of 26Majority line ForClear line For Cohesion 0.92
No groupFor 24Against 1Abst. 3No vote 1 of 29Majority line —Clear line No line Cohesion —

Members who changed group are counted in the group of the day: Branko GRIMS changed group, Elena YONCHEVA changed group, Elisabetta GUALMINI changed group, Ewa ZAJĄCZKOWSKA-HERNIK changed group, Fernand KARTHEISER changed group, Jessika VAN LEEUWEN changed group, Laurent CASTILLO changed group, Lukas SIEPER changed group, Malika SOREL changed group, Nikola BARTŮŠEK changed group, Nikolas FARANTOURIS changed group, Pina PICIERNO changed group, Roberto VANNACCI changed group, Sander SMIT changed group, Taner KABILOV changed group.

Voted against their group, 27

Members who voted otherwise than a clear line (at least two thirds of the votes cast, at least 10 members voting) of the group they sat in that day. A group without a clear line is divided and not counted.

Countries

The final vote by national delegation.

Votes by country (27 delegations)
Members' votes by country. No vote: in office that day, no position recorded. Cohesion: Agreement Index of the delegation, 0 = evenly split, 1 = all the same; it reflects the mix of groups (method).
CountryForAgainstAbst.No voteCohesion
Austria161030.91
Belgium118030.37
Bulgaria90530.46
Cyprus4110—
Czechia117030.42
Germany50293140.41
Denmark75030.38
Estonia1600—
Spain2725080.28
Finland86010.36
France740071.00
Greece200011.00
Croatia111000.88
Hungary180031.00
Ireland58010.42
Italy608080.82
Lithuania62300.32
Luxembourg2130—
Latvia7101—
Malta3201—
Netherlands2110000.52
Poland422450.81
Portugal118020.37
Romania2010120.47
Sweden1011000.29
Slovenia9000—
Slovakia140011.00

Members

Each member’s recorded position on the final roll call, in the group they sat in that day. Filter by country, group, position or name.

649 members with a recorded position.

Each member's recorded position. ≠ group: voted otherwise than a clear line (at least two thirds) of their group.
MemberCountryGroupPosition
Abir AL-SAHLANI SwedenRenew Against
Adam BIELAN PolandECR For
Adam JARUBAS PolandEPP Abstained
Adina VĂLEAN RomaniaEPP Against
Adnan DIBRANI SwedenS&D For
Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARA SpainEPP Against
Adrian-George AXINIA RomaniaECR For
Afroditi LATINOPOULOU GreecePatriots For
Alberico GAMBINO ItalyECR For
Aldo PATRICIELLO ItalyPatriots For
Aleksandar NIKOLIC FrancePatriots For
Alessandra MORETTI ItalyS&D For
Alessandro CIRIANI ItalyECR For
Alessandro ZAN ItalyS&D For
Alex AGIUS SALIBA MaltaS&D For
Alexander BERNHUBER AustriaEPP For
Alexander JUNGBLUTH GermanyESN For
Alexander SELL voted otherwise than their group's clear line GermanyESN Abstained
Alexandr VONDRA voted otherwise than their group's clear line CzechiaECR Against
Alexandra GEESE GermanyGreens For
Alexandra MEHNERT GermanyEPP Against
Alexandre VARAUT FrancePatriots For
Alice KUHNKE SwedenGreens For
Alice TEODORESCU MÅWE SwedenEPP Against
Alicia HOMS GINEL SpainS&D For
Alma EZCURRA ALMANSA SpainEPP Against
Alvise PÉREZ SpainNo group Against
Ana Catarina MENDES PortugalS&D For
Ana Miguel PEDRO PortugalEPP Against
Ana MIRANDA PAZ SpainGreens For
Ana VASCONCELOS PortugalRenew Against
Anders VISTISEN voted otherwise than their group's clear line DenmarkPatriots Against
Andi CRISTEA RomaniaS&D For
András GYÜRK HungaryPatriots For
András LÁSZLÓ HungaryPatriots For
András Tivadar KULJA HungaryEPP For
André ROUGÉ FrancePatriots For
Andrea WECHSLER GermanyEPP Against
Andreas SCHIEDER AustriaS&D For
Andreas SCHWAB GermanyEPP Against
Andrey KOVATCHEV BulgariaEPP Abstained
Andrey NOVAKOV BulgariaEPP Abstained
Andrzej BUŁA PolandEPP For
Andrzej HALICKI PolandEPP For
Angelika WINZIG AustriaEPP For
Angéline FURET FrancePatriots For
Anja ARNDT GermanyESN For
Anja HAZEKAMP NetherlandsThe Left For
Anna BRYŁKA PolandPatriots For
Anna CAVAZZINI GermanyGreens For
Anna Maria CISINT ItalyPatriots For
Anna STROLENBERG NetherlandsGreens For
Anna STÜRGKH AustriaRenew Against
Anna ZALEWSKA PolandECR For
Anna-Maja HENRIKSSON FinlandRenew For
Annalisa CORRADO ItalyS&D For
Annamária VICSEK HungaryPatriots For
Anne-Sophie FRIGOUT FrancePatriots For
Anouk VAN BRUG NetherlandsRenew Against
Anthony SMITH FranceThe Left For
Antonella SBERNA ItalyECR For
Antonio DECARO ItalyS&D For
Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE SpainEPP Against
António TÂNGER CORRÊA PortugalPatriots For
Aodhán Ó RÍORDÁIN IrelandS&D For
Arash SAEIDI FranceThe Left For
Arba KOKALARI SwedenEPP Against
Arkadiusz MULARCZYK PolandECR For
Assita KANKO voted otherwise than their group's clear line BelgiumECR Against
Auke ZIJLSTRA NetherlandsPatriots For
Aura SALLA FinlandEPP Against
Aurelijus VERYGA LithuaniaECR For
Aurore LALUCQ FranceS&D For
Axel VOSS GermanyEPP Against
Barbara BONTE BelgiumPatriots For
Barry ANDREWS IrelandRenew Against
Barry COWEN IrelandRenew For
Bart GROOTHUIS NetherlandsRenew Against
Bartłomiej SIENKIEWICZ PolandEPP Abstained
Bartosz ARŁUKOWICZ PolandEPP Against
Bas EICKHOUT NetherlandsGreens For
Beata SZYDŁO PolandECR For
Beatrice TIMGREN voted otherwise than their group's clear line SwedenECR Against
Benedetta SCUDERI ItalyGreens For
Benoit CASSART BelgiumRenew Against
Bernard GUETTA FranceRenew For
Bernd LANGE GermanyS&D For
Bert-Jan RUISSEN NetherlandsECR For
Biljana BORZAN CroatiaS&D For
Billy KELLEHER IrelandRenew Against
Birgit SIPPEL GermanyS&D For
Bogdan Andrzej ZDROJEWSKI PolandEPP For
Bogdan RZOŃCA PolandECR For
Borja GIMÉNEZ LARRAZ SpainEPP Against
Borys BUDKA PolandEPP For
Brando BENIFEI ItalyS&D For
Branko GRIMS SloveniaEPP For
Brigitte VAN DEN BERG NetherlandsRenew For
Bruno GONÇALVES PortugalS&D For
Camilla LAURETI ItalyS&D For
Carla TAVARES PortugalS&D For
Carlo FIDANZA ItalyECR For
Carmen CRESPO DÍAZ SpainEPP Against
Carola RACKETE GermanyThe Left For
Carolina MORACE ItalyThe Left For
Catarina MARTINS PortugalThe Left For
Catarina VIEIRA NetherlandsGreens For
Caterina CHINNICI ItalyEPP Against
Catherine GRISET FrancePatriots For
Cecilia STRADA ItalyS&D For
Céline IMART FranceEPP For
César LUENA SpainS&D For
Charles GOERENS LuxembourgRenew Against
Charlie WEIMERS voted otherwise than their group's clear line SwedenECR Against
Chiara GEMMA ItalyECR For
Chloé RIDEL FranceS&D For
Christel SCHALDEMOSE DenmarkS&D For
Christian EHLER GermanyEPP Against
Christine ANDERSON GermanyESN For
Christine SINGER GermanyRenew Against
Christophe BAY FrancePatriots For
Christophe GOMART FranceEPP For
Claire FITA FranceS&D For
Claudiu MANDA RomaniaS&D For
Claudiu-Richard TÂRZIU RomaniaECR For
Costas MAVRIDES CyprusS&D For
Cristian TERHEŞ RomaniaECR For
Cristina GUARDA ItalyGreens For
Cristina MAESTRE SpainS&D For
Csaba DÖMÖTÖR HungaryPatriots For
Cynthia NÍ MHURCHÚ IrelandRenew Against
Dainius ŽALIMAS LithuaniaRenew For
Damian BOESELAGER GermanyGreens For
Damien CARÊME FranceThe Left For
Dan BARNA RomaniaRenew For
Dan-Ştefan MOTREANU RomaniaEPP Against
Daniel ATTARD MaltaS&D For
Daniel BUDA RomaniaEPP Against
Daniel CASPARY GermanyEPP Against
Daniel FREUND GermanyGreens For
Daniel OBAJTEK PolandECR For
Daniele POLATO ItalyECR For
Danilo DELLA VALLE ItalyThe Left For
Dario NARDELLA ItalyS&D For
Dario TAMBURRANO ItalyThe Left For
Dariusz JOŃSKI PolandEPP For
David CASA MaltaEPP Against
David CORMAND FranceGreens For
David MCALLISTER GermanyEPP Against
Davor Ivo STIER CroatiaEPP For
Delara BURKHARDT GermanyS&D For
Denis NESCI ItalyECR For
Dennis RADTKE GermanyEPP Against
Diana IOVANOVICI ŞOŞOACĂ RomaniaNo group Abstained
Diana RIBA I GINER SpainGreens For
Dick ERIXON voted otherwise than their group's clear line SwedenECR Against
Diego SOLIER voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainECR Against
Dirk GOTINK NetherlandsEPP Against
Dominik TARCZYŃSKI PolandECR For
Dóra DÁVID HungaryEPP For
Dragoş BENEA RomaniaS&D For
Eero HEINÄLUOMA FinlandS&D For
Elena DONAZZAN ItalyECR For
Elena KOUNTOURA GreeceThe Left For
Elena NEVADO DEL CAMPO SpainEPP Against
Elena SANCHO MURILLO SpainS&D For
Elena YONCHEVA BulgariaNo group For
Eleonora MELETI GreeceEPP For
Elisabeth DIERINGER AustriaPatriots For
Elisabeth GROSSMANN AustriaS&D For
Elisabetta GUALMINI ItalyS&D For
Elissavet VOZEMBERG-VRIONIDI GreeceEPP For
Elsi KATAINEN FinlandRenew Against
Emil RADEV BulgariaEPP For
Emma FOURREAU FranceThe Left For
Emma RAFOWICZ FranceS&D For
Emma WIESNER SwedenRenew Against
Emmanouil FRAGKOS GreeceECR For
Emmanouil KEFALOGIANNIS GreeceEPP For
Eric SARGIACOMO FranceS&D For
Erik KALIŇÁK SlovakiaNo group For
Erik MARQUARDT GermanyGreens For
Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS HungaryPatriots For
Esteban GONZÁLEZ PONS SpainEPP Against
Estelle CEULEMANS BelgiumS&D For
Esther HERRANZ GARCÍA SpainEPP Against
Eszter LAKOS HungaryEPP For
Eugen TOMAC RomaniaRenew Against
Evelyn REGNER AustriaS&D For
Evin INCIR SwedenS&D For
Ewa KOPACZ PolandEPP For
Fabienne KELLER FranceRenew For
Fabio DE MASI GermanyNo group For
Fabrice LEGGERI FrancePatriots For
Fernand KARTHEISER voted otherwise than their group's clear line LuxembourgECR Abstained
Fernando NAVARRETE ROJAS SpainEPP Against
Fidias PANAYIOTOU CyprusNo group For
Filip TUREK CzechiaPatriots For
Flavio TOSI ItalyEPP Against
France JAMET FrancePatriots For
Francesco TORSELLI ItalyECR For
Francesco VENTOLA ItalyECR For
Francisco ASSIS PortugalS&D For
François KALFON FranceS&D For
François-Xavier BELLAMY FranceEPP For
Fredis BELERIS GreeceEPP For
Friedrich PÜRNER GermanyNo group For
Fulvio MARTUSCIELLO ItalyEPP Against
Gabriela FIREA RomaniaS&D For
Gabriele BISCHOFF GermanyS&D For
Gabriella GERZSENYI HungaryEPP For
Gaetano PEDULLA' ItalyThe Left For
Galato ALEXANDRAKI GreeceECR For
Geadis GEADI voted otherwise than their group's clear line CyprusECR Abstained
Georgiana TEODORESCU RomaniaECR For
Georgios AFTIAS GreeceEPP For
Gerald HAUSER AustriaPatriots For
Gerben-Jan GERBRANDY NetherlandsRenew For
Gerolf ANNEMANS BelgiumPatriots For
Gheorghe CÂRCIU RomaniaS&D For
Gheorghe FALCĂ RomaniaEPP Against
Gheorghe PIPEREA RomaniaECR For
Gilles BOYER FranceRenew For
Gilles PENNELLE FrancePatriots For
Giorgio GORI ItalyS&D For
Giorgos GEORGIOU CyprusThe Left For
Giovanni CROSETTO ItalyECR For
Giuseppe ANTOCI ItalyThe Left For
Giuseppe LUPO ItalyS&D For
Giusi PRINCI ItalyEPP Against
Gordan BOSANAC CroatiaGreens For
Grégory ALLIONE FranceRenew For
Grzegorz BRAUN PolandNo group Abstained
Guillaume PELTIER FranceECR For
Günther SIDL AustriaS&D For
György HÖLVÉNYI HungaryPatriots For
Hana JALLOUL MURO SpainS&D For
Hanna GEDIN SwedenThe Left For
Hanna GRONKIEWICZ-WALTZ PolandEPP For
Hannah NEUMANN GermanyGreens For
Hannes HEIDE AustriaS&D For
Hans NEUHOFF GermanyESN For
Harald VILIMSKY AustriaPatriots For
Heléne FRITZON SwedenS&D For
Henrik DAHL DenmarkEPP Against
Herbert DORFMANN ItalyEPP Against
Hermann TERTSCH voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainPatriots Against
Hilde VAUTMANS BelgiumRenew Against
Hildegard BENTELE GermanyEPP Against
Hristo PETROV BulgariaRenew For
Idoia MENDIA SpainS&D For
Ignazio Roberto MARINO ItalyGreens For
Ilaria SALIS ItalyThe Left For
Ilhan KYUCHYUK BulgariaRenew For
Ilia LAZAROV BulgariaEPP Abstained
Inese VAIDERE LatviaEPP For
Ingeborg TER LAAK NetherlandsEPP Against
Ioan-Rareş BOGDAN RomaniaEPP Against
Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ SpainS&D For
Irena JOVEVA SloveniaRenew For
Irene MONTERO SpainThe Left For
Irene TINAGLI ItalyS&D For
Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA SpainEPP Against
Isabel SERRA SÁNCHEZ SpainThe Left For
Isabel WISELER-LIMA LuxembourgEPP Abstained
Isabella LÖVIN SwedenGreens For
Isabella TOVAGLIERI ItalyPatriots For
Isabelle LE CALLENNEC FranceEPP For
Isilda GOMES PortugalS&D For
Iuliu WINKLER RomaniaEPP Against
Ivan DAVID CzechiaESN For
Ivars IJABS LatviaRenew Against
Ivaylo VALCHEV BulgariaECR For
Jaak MADISON voted otherwise than their group's clear line EstoniaECR Against
Jacek OZDOBA PolandECR For
Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA PolandECR For
Jagna MARCZUŁAJTIS-WALCZAK PolandEPP For
Jan FARSKÝ CzechiaEPP Against
Jan-Christoph OETJEN GermanyRenew Against
Jan-Peter WARNKE GermanyNo group For
Jana NAGYOVÁ CzechiaPatriots For
Jana TOOM EstoniaRenew For
Janusz LEWANDOWSKI PolandEPP Abstained
Jaroslav BŽOCH CzechiaPatriots For
Jaume ASENS LLODRÀ SpainGreens For
Javi LÓPEZ SpainS&D For
Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ SpainS&D For
Jean-Marc GERMAIN FranceS&D For
Jean-Paul GARRAUD FrancePatriots For
Jeannette BALJEU NetherlandsRenew Against
Jens GEIER GermanyS&D For
Jens GIESEKE GermanyEPP Against
Jeroen LENAERS NetherlandsEPP Against
Jessica POLFJÄRD SwedenEPP Against
Jessika VAN LEEUWEN NetherlandsEPP Against
Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI PolandECR For
Joachim STREIT GermanyRenew Against
Joanna SCHEURING-WIELGUS PolandS&D For
João COTRIM DE FIGUEIREDO PortugalRenew Against
João OLIVEIRA PortugalThe Left For
Johan DANIELSSON SwedenS&D For
Johan VAN OVERTVELDT voted otherwise than their group's clear line BelgiumECR Against
Jonás FERNÁNDEZ SpainS&D For
Jonas SJÖSTEDT SwedenThe Left For
Jordan BARDELLA FrancePatriots For
Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainPatriots Against
Jorge MARTÍN FRÍAS voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainPatriots Against
Jörgen WARBORN SwedenEPP Against
José CEPEDA SpainS&D For
Juan Carlos GIRAUTA VIDAL voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainPatriots Against
Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR SpainS&D For
Judita LAŠŠÁKOVÁ SlovakiaNo group For
Julie RECHAGNEUX FrancePatriots For
Julien SANCHEZ FrancePatriots For
Jüri RATAS EstoniaEPP Against
Jussi SARAMO FinlandThe Left For
Jutta PAULUS GermanyGreens For
Kai TEGETHOFF GermanyGreens For
Kamila GASIUK-PIHOWICZ PolandEPP For
Karin KARLSBRO SwedenRenew Against
Karlo RESSLER CroatiaEPP For
Katarina BARLEY GermanyS&D For
Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ SlovakiaNo group For
Kateřina KONEČNÁ CzechiaNo group For
Kathleen FUNCHION IrelandThe Left For
Kathleen VAN BREMPT BelgiumS&D For
Katri KULMUNI FinlandRenew Against
Katrin LANGENSIEPEN GermanyGreens For
Kim VAN SPARRENTAK NetherlandsGreens For
Kinga GÁL HungaryPatriots For
Kinga KOLLÁR HungaryEPP For
Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN DenmarkGreens For
Klára DOBREV HungaryS&D For
Klara DOSTALOVA CzechiaPatriots For
Konstantinos ARVANITIS GreeceThe Left For
Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI PolandECR For
Kostas PAPADAKIS GreeceNo group For
Kris VAN DIJCK voted otherwise than their group's clear line BelgiumECR Against
Krzysztof BREJZA PolandEPP For
Krzysztof HETMAN PolandEPP For
Krzysztof ŚMISZEK PolandS&D For
Lara MAGONI ItalyECR For
Lara WOLTERS NetherlandsS&D For
Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA SpainS&D For
Laurence FARRENG FranceRenew For
Laurence TROCHU FranceECR For
Laurent CASTILLO FranceEPP For
Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS GreeceNo group For
Leila CHAIBI FranceThe Left For
Leire PAJÍN SpainS&D For
Lena DÜPONT GermanyEPP Against
Lena SCHILLING AustriaGreens For
Li ANDERSSON FinlandThe Left For
Lídia PEREIRA PortugalEPP Against
Liesbet SOMMEN BelgiumEPP Against
Lina GÁLVEZ SpainS&D For
Liudas MAŽYLIS LithuaniaEPP Against
Loránt VINCZE RomaniaEPP For
Loucas FOURLAS CyprusEPP For
Ľubica KARVAŠOVÁ SlovakiaRenew For
Ľuboš BLAHA SlovakiaNo group For
Lucia ANNUNZIATA ItalyS&D For
Lucia YAR SlovakiaRenew For
Luděk NIEDERMAYER CzechiaEPP Against
Ľudovít ÓDOR SlovakiaRenew For
Luis-Vicențiu LAZARUS RomaniaNo group For
Lukas MANDL AustriaEPP For
Lukas SIEPER GermanyNo group For
Łukasz KOHUT PolandEPP For
Luke Ming FLANAGAN IrelandThe Left For
Lynn BOYLAN IrelandThe Left For
Maciej WĄSIK PolandECR For
Magdalena ADAMOWICZ PolandEPP For
Majdouline SBAI FranceGreens For
Małgorzata GOSIEWSKA PolandECR For
Malik AZMANI NetherlandsRenew Against
Malika SOREL FrancePatriots For
Manfred WEBER GermanyEPP Against
Manon AUBRY FranceThe Left For
Manuela RIPA GermanyEPP For
Maravillas ABADÍA JOVER SpainEPP Against
Marc ANGEL LuxembourgS&D For
Marc BOTENGA BelgiumThe Left For
Marcin SYPNIEWSKI PolandESN For
Marco TARQUINIO ItalyS&D For
Marcos ROS SEMPERE SpainS&D For
Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainPatriots Against
Maria GRAPINI RomaniaS&D For
Maria GUZENINA FinlandS&D For
Maria NOICHL GermanyS&D For
Maria OHISALO FinlandGreens For
Maria WALSH IrelandEPP Against
Maria ZACHARIA GreeceNo group For
Marianne VIND DenmarkS&D For
Mariateresa VIVALDINI voted otherwise than their group's clear line ItalyECR Against
Marie DAUCHY FrancePatriots For
Marie TOUSSAINT FranceGreens For
Marie-Agnes STRACK-ZIMMERMANN GermanyRenew Against
Marie-Luce BRASIER-CLAIN FrancePatriots For
Marie-Pierre VEDRENNE FranceRenew For
Marieke EHLERS NetherlandsPatriots For
Marina KALJURAND voted otherwise than their group's clear line EstoniaS&D Against
Marina MESURE FranceThe Left For
Mario FURORE ItalyThe Left For
Mario MANTOVANI ItalyECR For
Marion MARÉCHAL FranceECR For
Marion WALSMANN GermanyEPP Against
Marit MAIJ NetherlandsS&D For
Mariusz KAMIŃSKI PolandECR For
Marjan ŠAREC SloveniaRenew For
Markéta GREGOROVÁ CzechiaGreens For
Marko VEŠLIGAJ CroatiaS&D For
Markus BUCHHEIT GermanyESN For
Markus FERBER GermanyEPP For
Marlena MALĄG PolandECR For
Marta TEMIDO PortugalS&D For
Marta WCISŁO PolandEPP For
Martin HÄUSLING GermanyGreens For
Martin HOJSÍK SlovakiaRenew For
Martin SCHIRDEWAN GermanyThe Left For
Martin SONNEBORN GermanyNo group For
Martine KEMP LuxembourgEPP Abstained
Mārtiņš STAĶIS LatviaGreens For
Massimiliano SALINI ItalyEPP Against
Matej TONIN SloveniaEPP For
Mathilde ANDROUËT FrancePatriots For
Matjaž NEMEC SloveniaS&D For
Matteo RICCI ItalyS&D For
Matthias ECKE GermanyS&D For
Matthieu VALET FrancePatriots For
Maximilian KRAH GermanyNo group Abstained
Mélanie DISDIER FrancePatriots For
Mélissa CAMARA FranceGreens For
Merja KYLLÖNEN FinlandThe Left For
Michael BLOSS GermanyGreens For
Michael GAHLER GermanyEPP Against
Michael MCNAMARA IrelandRenew Against
Michael VON DER SCHULENBURG GermanyNo group For
Michał KOBOSKO PolandRenew Against
Michał SZCZERBA PolandEPP For
Michał WAWRYKIEWICZ PolandEPP For
Michal WIEZIK SlovakiaRenew For
Michalis HADJIPANTELA CyprusEPP Against
Michele PICARO ItalyECR For
Mihai TUDOSE RomaniaS&D For
Mika AALTOLA FinlandEPP Against
Milan MAZUREK SlovakiaESN For
Milan UHRÍK SlovakiaESN For
Milan ZVER SloveniaEPP For
Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA RomaniaEPP Against
Mireia BORRÁS PABÓN voted otherwise than their group's clear line SpainPatriots Against
Miriam LEXMANN SlovakiaEPP For
Mirosława NYKIEL PolandEPP For
Mohammed CHAHIM NetherlandsS&D For
Monika BEŇOVÁ SlovakiaNo group For
Monika HOHLMEIER GermanyEPP For
Moritz KÖRNER GermanyRenew Against
Morten LØKKEGAARD DenmarkRenew Against
Mounir SATOURI FranceGreens For
Murielle LAURENT FranceS&D For
Nela RIEHL GermanyGreens For
Niclas HERBST GermanyEPP Against
Nicola PROCACCINI ItalyECR For
Nicola ZINGARETTI ItalyS&D For
Nicolae ȘTEFĂNUȚĂ RomaniaGreens For
Nicolas BAY FranceECR For
Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES SpainS&D For
Nicolás PASCUAL DE LA PARTE SpainEPP Against
Niels Flemming HANSEN DenmarkEPP Against
Niels GEUKING GermanyEPP Abstained
Nikola BARTŮŠEK CzechiaPatriots For
Nikola MINCHEV BulgariaRenew Abstained
Nikolaos ANADIOTIS GreeceNo group For
Nikolas FARANTOURIS GreeceThe Left For
Nikolina BRNJAC CroatiaEPP For
Nikos PAPANDREOU GreeceS&D For
Nikos PAPPAS GreeceThe Left For
Nina CARBERRY IrelandEPP Against
Nora MEBAREK FranceS&D For
Norbert LINS GermanyEPP Against
Oihane AGIRREGOITIA MARTÍNEZ SpainRenew For
Oliver SCHENK GermanyEPP Against
Olivier CHASTEL BelgiumRenew Against
Ondřej DOSTÁL CzechiaNo group For
Ondřej KNOTEK CzechiaPatriots For
Ondřej KOLÁŘ CzechiaEPP Against
Ondřej KRUTÍLEK voted otherwise than their group's clear line CzechiaECR Against
Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA SpainEPP Against
Pál SZEKERES HungaryPatriots For
Paolo BORCHIA ItalyPatriots For
Paolo INSELVINI ItalyECR For
Pär HOLMGREN SwedenGreens For
Pascal ARIMONT BelgiumEPP For
Pascal CANFIN FranceRenew For
Pascale PIERA FrancePatriots For
Pasquale TRIDICO ItalyThe Left For
Patryk JAKI PolandECR For
Paulius SAUDARGAS LithuaniaEPP Against
Paulo CUNHA PortugalEPP Against
Paulo DO NASCIMENTO CABRAL PortugalEPP Against
Pekka TOVERI FinlandEPP Against
Per CLAUSEN DenmarkThe Left For
Pernando BARRENA ARZA SpainThe Left For
Petar VOLGIN BulgariaESN For
Peter AGIUS MaltaEPP Against
Peter LIESE GermanyEPP Against
Petr BYSTRON GermanyESN For
Petra STEGER AustriaPatriots For
Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS LithuaniaRenew For
Petras GRAŽULIS LithuaniaESN For
Philippe OLIVIER FrancePatriots For
Pierfrancesco MARAN ItalyS&D For
Pierre JOUVET FranceS&D For
Pierre PIMPIE FrancePatriots For
Pierre-Romain THIONNET FrancePatriots For
Pilar DEL CASTILLO VERA SpainEPP Against
Pina PICIERNO ItalyS&D For
Piotr MÜLLER PolandECR For
Rachel BLOM NetherlandsPatriots For
Rada LAYKOVA BulgariaESN For
Radan KANEV BulgariaEPP Abstained
Raffaele STANCANELLI ItalyPatriots For
Raffaele TOPO ItalyS&D For
Ralf SEEKATZ GermanyEPP Against
Raphaël GLUCKSMANN FranceS&D For
Raquel GARCÍA HERMIDA-VAN DER WALLE NetherlandsRenew For
Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ LithuaniaEPP Abstained
Rasmus ANDRESEN GermanyGreens For
Rasmus NORDQVIST DenmarkGreens For
Raúl DE LA HOZ QUINTANO SpainEPP Against
Regina DOHERTY IrelandEPP Against
Reinhold LOPATKA AustriaEPP For
Reinier VAN LANSCHOT NetherlandsGreens For
Reinis POZŅAKS LatviaECR For
René AUST GermanyESN For
René REPASI GermanyS&D For
Rihards KOLS LatviaECR For
Riho TERRAS EstoniaEPP Against
Rima HASSAN FranceThe Left For
Robert BIEDROŃ PolandS&D For
Roberto VANNACCI ItalyPatriots For
Roberts ZĪLE LatviaECR For
Rody TOLASSY FrancePatriots For
Roman HAIDER AustriaPatriots For
Romana JERKOVIĆ CroatiaS&D For
Romana TOMC SloveniaEPP For
Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT SpainEPP Against
Rosa SERRANO SIERRA SpainS&D For
Rudi KENNES BelgiumThe Left For
Ruggero RAZZA ItalyECR For
Ruth FIRMENICH GermanyNo group For
Sabrina REPP GermanyS&D For
Sakis ARNAOUTOGLOU GreeceS&D For
Salvatore DE MEO ItalyEPP Against
Sander SMIT NetherlandsEPP Against
Sandra GÓMEZ LÓPEZ SpainS&D For
Sandra KALNIETE LatviaEPP For
Sandro GOZI FranceRenew For
Sandro RUOTOLO ItalyS&D For
Sara MATTHIEU BelgiumGreens For
Sarah KNAFO FranceESN For
Saskia BRICMONT BelgiumGreens For
Seán KELLY IrelandEPP Against
Sebastiaan STÖTELER NetherlandsPatriots For
Sebastian KRUIS NetherlandsPatriots For
Sebastian TYNKKYNEN voted otherwise than their group's clear line FinlandECR Against
Sebastião BUGALHO PortugalEPP Against
Şerban Dimitrie STURDZA RomaniaECR For
Sergey LAGODINSKY GermanyGreens For
Sergio BERLATO ItalyECR For
Sérgio GONÇALVES PortugalS&D For
Sérgio HUMBERTO PortugalEPP Against
Séverine WERBROUCK FrancePatriots For
Sibylle BERG GermanyNo group For
Siegfried MUREŞAN RomaniaEPP Against
Sigrid FRIIS DenmarkRenew For
Silvia SARDONE ItalyPatriots For
Sofie ERIKSSON SwedenS&D For
Stanisław TYSZKA PolandESN For
Stefan BERGER GermanyEPP Against
Stefan KÖHLER GermanyEPP Against
Stefano BONACCINI ItalyS&D For
Stefano CAVEDAGNA ItalyECR For
Stéphanie YON-COURTIN FranceRenew For
Stephen Nikola BARTULICA CroatiaECR For
Stine BOSSE DenmarkRenew Against
Sunčana GLAVAK CroatiaEPP For
Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ SpainEPP Against
Susanna CECCARDI ItalyPatriots For
Sven MIKSER voted otherwise than their group's clear line EstoniaS&D Against
Sven SIMON GermanyEPP Against
Svenja HAHN GermanyRenew Against
Tamás DEUTSCH HungaryPatriots For
Taner KABILOV BulgariaNo group For
Terry REINTKE GermanyGreens For
Thierry MARIANI FrancePatriots For
Thijs REUTEN NetherlandsS&D For
Thomas BAJADA MaltaS&D For
Thomas GEISEL GermanyNo group For
Thomas PELLERIN-CARLIN FranceS&D For
Thomas WAITZ AustriaGreens For
Tiago MOREIRA DE SÁ PortugalPatriots For
Tilly METZ LuxembourgGreens For
Tineke STRIK NetherlandsGreens For
Tobias CREMER GermanyS&D For
Tobiasz BOCHEŃSKI PolandECR For
Tom BERENDSEN NetherlandsEPP Against
Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE BelgiumPatriots For
Tomáš KUBÍN CzechiaPatriots For
Tomas TOBÉ SwedenEPP Against
Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ CzechiaEPP Against
Tomasz BUCZEK PolandPatriots For
Tomasz FROELICH GermanyESN For
Tomislav SOKOL CroatiaEPP For
Ton DIEPEVEEN NetherlandsPatriots For
Tonino PICULA CroatiaS&D For
Tsvetelina PENKOVA BulgariaS&D For
Udo BULLMANN GermanyS&D For
Urmas PAET EstoniaRenew Against
Valentina PALMISANO ItalyThe Left For
Valérie DELOGE FrancePatriots For
Valérie HAYER FranceRenew For
Vangelis MEIMARAKIS GreeceEPP For
Vasile DÎNCU RomaniaS&D For
Verena MERTENS GermanyEPP Against
Veronika CIFROVÁ OSTRIHOŇOVÁ SlovakiaRenew For
Veronika VRECIONOVÁ voted otherwise than their group's clear line CzechiaECR Against
Vicent MARZÀ IBÁÑEZ SpainGreens For
Victor NEGRESCU RomaniaS&D For
Viktória FERENC HungaryPatriots For
Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ LithuaniaS&D For
Vilis KRIŠTOPANS LatviaPatriots For
Ville NIINISTÖ FinlandGreens For
Villy SØVNDAL DenmarkGreens For
Virgil-Daniel POPESCU RomaniaEPP Against
Virginie JORON FrancePatriots For
Virginijus SINKEVIČIUS voted otherwise than their group's clear line LithuaniaGreens Abstained
Vivien COSTANZO GermanyS&D For
Vlad VASILE-VOICULESCU RomaniaRenew For
Vladimir PREBILIČ SloveniaGreens For
Vytenis Povilas ANDRIUKAITIS voted otherwise than their group's clear line LithuaniaS&D Abstained
Waldemar TOMASZEWSKI LithuaniaECR For
Wouter BEKE BelgiumEPP Against
Yannis MANIATIS GreeceS&D For
Yvan VEROUGSTRAETE BelgiumRenew For
Zala ČERNILEC TOMAŠIČ SloveniaEPP For
Željana ZOVKO CroatiaEPP Against
Zoltán TARR HungaryEPP For
Zsuzsanna BORVENDÉG HungaryESN For

Debate speakers and how they voted

Members who spoke in the plenary debate on the dossier. Speeches: how many times they took the floor. Final vote: their recorded position on this decision's final roll call.
MemberGroupSpeechesSpokeFinal vote
Sophie WILMÈS BelgiumRenewSpeeches112 Feb 2025 (verbatim report, official site) No vote recorded

All votes on this decision, 4

In voting order. Result: for–against–abstained (a show of hands has no count). Requested by: the groups that asked for a roll call, a split vote or a separate vote.
No.VoteRecordedResultRequested by
1Amendment 3, adding text after paragraph 4 B10-0061/2025 – After § 4 – Am 3 Roll call262 for, 309 against, 76 abstained RejectedRequested byroll call: The Left
2Vote on text inserted after citation 8 Show of hands Rejected
3Amendment 2, adding text after recital V B10-0061/2025 – After recital V – Am 2 Roll call290 for, 249 against, 110 abstained AdoptedRequested byroll call: The Left
4Final vote — text as a whole B10-0061/2025 – Motion for a resolution (as a whole) Roll call477 for, 152 against, 20 abstained AdoptedRequested byroll call: Greens, The Left
Show the other 3 votesShow the other 0 votes
Votes on this decision, continued
No.VoteRecordedResultRequested by
2Vote on text inserted after citation 8 Show of hands Rejected
3Amendment 2, adding text after recital V B10-0061/2025 – After recital V – Am 2 Roll call290 for, 249 against, 110 abstained AdoptedRequested byroll call: The Left
4Final vote — text as a whole B10-0061/2025 – Motion for a resolution (as a whole) Roll call477 for, 152 against, 20 abstained AdoptedRequested byroll call: Greens, The Left

Roll calls requested by The Left, Greens.

Text

The text voted on.

Motion B-10-2025-0061

AI: What this vote decides Written by AI from the official text — check the source

The European Parliament objected to the Commission's draft decision authorising the placing on the market of products containing, consisting of or produced from genetically modified maize DP910521.

The objection was adopted, meaning the Commission measure is blocked and the maize cannot be authorised for sale in the EU.

The resolution cites concerns about the herbicide glufosinate, the Cry1B.34 toxin, and inadequate risk assessment.

Read the text · Report a problem

AI: The text in short Written by AI from the official text — check the source

Parliament objects to the Commission's draft decision authorising genetically modified maize DP910521, citing risks to health, biodiversity, and the environment, and calls for its withdrawal.

Read the text · Report a problem

Dossier

Where the dossier stands and its other decisions in plenary.

2024/3010(RSP) · Resolution on a topical subject

Objection pursuant to Rule 115(2) and (3) authorising the placing on the market of products containing, consisting of or produced from genetically modified maize DP910521 pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1829/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council

Parliament adopted the text on 12 February 2025. This is its final position on the matter.

Show the 3 steps of the dossier
  1. Tabled for plenary (done)
  2. Plenary vote · Adopted 12 February 2025 (done)
  3. Parliament’s position · Final (done)

Lead committee: ENVI · Authors: Biljana BORZAN (S&D), Martin HÄUSLING (Greens), Anja HAZEKAMP (The Left)

Connections

What this decision touches: the procedural chain, the same text, running issues, votes that split the chamber the same way.

Show 6 connections: Other decisions of the part-session on ENVI dossiers · Final votes that split the chamber the same way

Other decisions of the part-session on ENVI dossiers

See all: Other decisions of the part-session on ENVI dossiers

Final votes that split the chamber the same way

Sources & citation

Where the facts on this page come from, and how to cite it.

Retrieved
25 September 2026

Cite as

European Parliament (2025). “Genetically modified maize DP910521”. Decision, 12 February 2025. votingId 171793, document B-10-2025-0061, reference 2024/3010(RSP). EU Parl Watch Research. https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-02-12/3?members=all (retrieved 25 September 2026). Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 12 February 2025 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-02-12-RCV_EN.html; Results of votes, sitting of 12 February 2025 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-02-12-VOT_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2025-02-12, https://data.europarl.europa.eu/api/v2/meetings/MTG-PL-2025-02-12/decisions?format=application%2Fld%2Bjson (CC BY 4.0).
BibTeX
@misc{epw-decision-2025-02-12-3,
  author = {{European Parliament}},
  title = {{Genetically modified maize DP910521}},
  year = {2025},
  date = {2025-02-12},
  howpublished = {\url{https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-02-12/3?members=all}},
  url = {https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-02-12/3?members=all},
  urldate = {2026-09-25},
  publisher = {EU Parl Watch Research},
  note = {Decision. votingId 171793, document B-10-2025-0061, reference 2024/3010(RSP). Official source: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-02-12-RCV\_EN.html, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-02-12-VOT\_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2025-02-12 (CC BY 4.0)}
}