Vote · Roll call
Separate vote: paragraph 5
Separate vote: paragraph 5
- Vote
- Separate vote: paragraph 5
- Decision
- Not linked to a decision
- Result
- 409 for · 164 against · 29 abstained · roll call
- Date
- 22 November 2023, 14:44
More facts (2)
- Official label
- A9-0337/2023 – Guy Verhofstadt, Sven Simon, Gabriele Bischoff, Daniel Freund, Helmut Scholz – § 5
- Vote id
- 161594
Export
- CSV
- JSON
- Country × group (CSV)
- Country × group (JSON)
- The members file includes members in office who did not vote.
More
The members file includes members in office who did not vote.
Roll-call results (EP) (opens the official site)Result
The vote as recorded by name.
Result: 409 for, 164 against, 29 abstained (roll call).
· 68 % of the votes cast were for.
Groups
Members counted in their current group: the view with groups at the date of the vote is not available right now.
| Group | For | Against | Abst. | Majority line | Clear line | Bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S&D | For 55 | Against 8 | Abst. 0 | Majority line For | Clear line For | |
| Renew | For 30 | Against 6 | Abst. 0 | Majority line For | Clear line For | |
| EPP | For 66 | Against 19 | Abst. 0 | Majority line For | Clear line For | |
| Greens | For 25 | Against 0 | Abst. 0 | Majority line For | Clear line For | |
| Patriots | For 3 | Against 23 | Abst. 4 | Majority line Against | Clear line Against | |
| The Left | For 11 | Against 1 | Abst. 0 | Majority line For | Clear line For | |
| No group | For 2 | Against 0 | Abst. 2 | Majority line — | Clear line No line | |
| ECR | For 2 | Against 23 | Abst. 1 | Majority line Against | Clear line Against | |
| ESN | For 0 | Against 3 | Abst. 0 | Majority line Against | Clear line Against |
Countries × groups
How each country’s members of each group voted.
The breakdown by country is not available right now.
Members
Each member’s recorded position — groups as of today: the view with groups at the date of the vote is not available right now.
602 members with a recorded position.
| Member | Country | Group | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abir AL-SAHLANI voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | Renew | Against |
| Adam BIELAN | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Aldo PATRICIELLO voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Italy | Patriots | For |
| Alessandra MORETTI | Italy | S&D | For |
| Alex AGIUS SALIBA | Malta | S&D | For |
| Alexander BERNHUBER voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Austria | EPP | Against |
| Alexandr VONDRA | Czechia | ECR | Against |
| Alexandra GEESE | Germany | Greens | For |
| Alice KUHNKE | Sweden | Greens | For |
| Alicia HOMS GINEL | Spain | S&D | For |
| Ana MIRANDA PAZ | Spain | Greens | For |
| András GYÜRK | Hungary | Patriots | Against |
| André ROUGÉ | France | Patriots | Against |
| Andreas GLÜCK | Germany | Renew | For |
| Andreas SCHIEDER | Austria | S&D | For |
| Andreas SCHWAB voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Germany | EPP | Against |
| Andrey KOVATCHEV | Bulgaria | EPP | For |
| Andrey NOVAKOV | Bulgaria | EPP | For |
| Andrzej HALICKI | Poland | EPP | For |
| Angelika NIEBLER | Germany | EPP | For |
| Anja HAZEKAMP | Netherlands | The Left | For |
| Anna CAVAZZINI | Germany | Greens | For |
| Anna ZALEWSKA | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE | Spain | EPP | For |
| Arba KOKALARI voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | EPP | Against |
| Asger CHRISTENSEN voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Denmark | Renew | Against |
| Assita KANKO | Belgium | ECR | Against |
| Aurore LALUCQ | France | S&D | For |
| Barry ANDREWS | Ireland | Renew | For |
| Bart GROOTHUIS voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Netherlands | Renew | Against |
| Beata SZYDŁO | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Bernard GUETTA | France | Renew | For |
| Bernd LANGE voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Germany | S&D | Against |
| Bert-Jan RUISSEN | Netherlands | ECR | Against |
| Biljana BORZAN | Croatia | S&D | For |
| Billy KELLEHER | Ireland | Renew | For |
| Birgit SIPPEL | Germany | S&D | For |
| Bogdan RZOŃCA | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Brando BENIFEI | Italy | S&D | For |
| Camilla LAURETI voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Italy | S&D | Against |
| Carlo FIDANZA | Italy | ECR | Against |
| Caterina CHINNICI | Italy | EPP | For |
| Catherine GRISET | France | Patriots | Against |
| César LUENA | Spain | S&D | For |
| Charles GOERENS | Luxembourg | Renew | For |
| Charlie WEIMERS | Sweden | ECR | Against |
| Chiara GEMMA | Italy | ECR | Against |
| Christel SCHALDEMOSE voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Denmark | S&D | Against |
| Christian DOLESCHAL | Germany | EPP | For |
| Christophe CLERGEAU | France | S&D | For |
| Christophe GRUDLER voted otherwise than their group's clear line | France | Renew | Against |
| Claudiu MANDA | Romania | S&D | For |
| Costas MAVRIDES | Cyprus | S&D | For |
| Cristian TERHEŞ | Romania | ECR | Against |
| Cristina MAESTRE | Spain | S&D | For |
| Csaba MOLNÁR | Hungary | S&D | For |
| Damian BOESELAGER | Germany | Greens | For |
| Damien CARÊME | France | The Left | For |
| Dan NICA | Romania | S&D | For |
| Dan-Ştefan MOTREANU | Romania | EPP | For |
| Daniel BUDA | Romania | EPP | For |
| Daniel FREUND | Germany | Greens | For |
| David CASA voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Malta | EPP | Against |
| David CORMAND | France | Greens | For |
| David MCALLISTER | Germany | EPP | For |
| Delara BURKHARDT | Germany | S&D | For |
| Denis NESCI | Italy | ECR | Against |
| Dennis RADTKE | Germany | EPP | For |
| Diana RIBA I GINER | Spain | Greens | For |
| Dolors MONTSERRAT voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Spain | EPP | Against |
| Dominik TARCZYŃSKI | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Dragoş BENEA | Romania | S&D | For |
| Eero HEINÄLUOMA voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Finland | S&D | Against |
| Elena KOUNTOURA | Greece | The Left | For |
| Elena YONCHEVA voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Bulgaria | ECR | For |
| Elisabetta GUALMINI | Italy | Renew | For |
| Elissavet VOZEMBERG-VRIONIDI | Greece | EPP | For |
| Elsi KATAINEN voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Finland | Renew | Against |
| Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA | Poland | EPP | For |
| Emma WIESNER voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | Renew | Against |
| Emmanouil FRAGKOS voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Greece | ECR | Abstained |
| Emmanouil KEFALOGIANNIS | Greece | EPP | For |
| Engin EROGLU | Germany | Renew | For |
| Enikő GYŐRI | Hungary | Patriots | Against |
| Erik MARQUARDT | Germany | Greens | For |
| Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS | Hungary | Patriots | Against |
| Eva MAYDELL | Bulgaria | EPP | For |
| Evelyn REGNER | Austria | S&D | For |
| Evin INCIR voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | S&D | Against |
| Ewa KOPACZ | Poland | EPP | For |
| Fabienne KELLER | France | Renew | For |
| Former MEP #112611 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #114268 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #118949 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124586 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124692 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124693 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124696 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124708 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124710 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124714 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124726 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124734 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124735 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #124738 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124739 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124747 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124777 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124780 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #124781 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #124812 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124821 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124822 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124833 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124835 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124844 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124856 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124862 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124872 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124873 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124875 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124887 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124891 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #124929 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124934 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124936 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124988 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124992 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #124996 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #125004 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125005 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125021 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125038 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125043 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125045 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125064 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125109 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125128 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125214 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125237 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #125706 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #126644 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #127096 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #130256 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #131507 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #132191 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #132366 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #134605 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #136236 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #183338 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #183793 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #185974 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #1892 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #189525 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #190518 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #190519 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #190774 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #192634 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #192635 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197390 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197393 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197415 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197418 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197419 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197422 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197423 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197427 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197431 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197436 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197437 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197438 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197441 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197446 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197451 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197452 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197453 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197455 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197457 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197458 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197459 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197465 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197467 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197472 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197478 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197480 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197481 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197483 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197489 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197495 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197502 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197505 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197506 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197507 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197508 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197510 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197511 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197512 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197513 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197515 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197518 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197519 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197522 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197526 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197527 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197530 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197531 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197532 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197536 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197538 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197539 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197540 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197541 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197542 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197544 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197546 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197547 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197548 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197550 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197551 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197559 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197563 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197564 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197566 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197567 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197571 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197584 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197586 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197587 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197588 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197590 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197596 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197608 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197610 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197611 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197616 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197619 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197626 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197629 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197634 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197635 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197637 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197638 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197641 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197645 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197650 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197654 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197657 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197665 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197667 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197668 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197671 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197675 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197680 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197692 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197695 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197709 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197717 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197720 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197728 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197731 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197742 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197754 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197764 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197766 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197767 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197771 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197776 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197777 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197778 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197779 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197783 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197785 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197787 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197788 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197791 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197796 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197798 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197799 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197804 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197805 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197808 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197817 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197819 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197822 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197826 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #197827 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197828 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197835 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197836 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197843 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197844 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197846 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197848 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197849 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197868 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197889 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #197894 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #197935 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #198063 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #198096 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #198329 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #199996 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #202112 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #202351 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #202352 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #204334 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #204335 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #204368 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #204416 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #204420 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #204421 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #204443 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #2054 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #205452 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #209091 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #209140 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #209896 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #212855 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #218349 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #221463 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #226260 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #229352 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #229519 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #2323 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #234344 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #236051 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #236052 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #23712 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #237224 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #237320 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #23768 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #237779 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #238639 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #239255 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #239256 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #239257 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #239258 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #239262 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #239271 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #239972 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #239973 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #240478 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #243912 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #243979 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #24505 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #245858 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #24594 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #247122 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #247709 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #247737 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #249284 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #249285 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #249826 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #250235 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #27714 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #28161 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28219 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28266 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28269 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28288 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28294 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28297 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #28340 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28346 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28353 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #28429 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28586 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #28619 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #29579 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #33982 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #33997 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #35016 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #38398 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #38420 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #38595 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #4246 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #4344 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #4560 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #5565 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #58789 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #88715 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96646 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96648 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96698 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #96713 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #96725 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96734 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96743 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96747 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #96750 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96771 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| Former MEP #96772 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96775 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96776 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96779 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96796 | Former MEPs | Against | |
| Former MEP #96820 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96852 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96867 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96868 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96880 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96885 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96891 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96899 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96903 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96922 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96952 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #96991 | Former MEPs | For | |
| Former MEP #99283 | Former MEPs | Abstained | |
| France JAMET | France | Patriots | Against |
| Francisco José MILLÁN MON | Spain | EPP | For |
| François-Xavier BELLAMY voted otherwise than their group's clear line | France | EPP | Against |
| Fulvio MARTUSCIELLO | Italy | EPP | For |
| Gabriel MATO | Spain | EPP | For |
| Gabriele BISCHOFF | Germany | S&D | For |
| Georg MAYER | Austria | Patriots | Against |
| Gerolf ANNEMANS voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Belgium | Patriots | For |
| Gilles BOYER | France | Renew | For |
| Giorgos GEORGIOU | Cyprus | The Left | For |
| Giuseppe MILAZZO | Italy | ECR | Against |
| Günther SIDL | Austria | S&D | For |
| György HÖLVÉNYI | Hungary | Patriots | Against |
| Hannah NEUMANN | Germany | Greens | For |
| Hannes HEIDE | Austria | S&D | For |
| Harald VILIMSKY | Austria | Patriots | Against |
| Heléne FRITZON voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | S&D | Against |
| Herbert DORFMANN | Italy | EPP | For |
| Hermann TERTSCH | Spain | Patriots | Against |
| Hilde VAUTMANS | Belgium | Renew | For |
| Hildegard BENTELE voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Germany | EPP | Against |
| Ilhan KYUCHYUK | Bulgaria | Renew | For |
| Inese VAIDERE | Latvia | EPP | For |
| Ioan-Rareş BOGDAN | Romania | EPP | For |
| Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ | Spain | S&D | For |
| Irena JOVEVA | Slovenia | Renew | For |
| Irene TINAGLI | Italy | S&D | For |
| Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA | Spain | EPP | For |
| Isabella TOVAGLIERI voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Italy | Patriots | Abstained |
| Iuliu WINKLER voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Romania | EPP | Against |
| Ivan DAVID | Czechia | ESN | Against |
| Ivars IJABS | Latvia | Renew | For |
| Jaak MADISON | Estonia | ECR | Against |
| Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Jan-Christoph OETJEN | Germany | Renew | For |
| Janusz LEWANDOWSKI | Poland | EPP | For |
| Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ | Spain | S&D | For |
| Javier ZARZALEJOS | Spain | EPP | For |
| Jean-Paul GARRAUD | France | Patriots | Against |
| Jens GEIER | Germany | S&D | For |
| Jens GIESEKE | Germany | EPP | For |
| Jérémy DECERLE | France | Renew | For |
| Jeroen LENAERS voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Netherlands | EPP | Against |
| Jessica POLFJÄRD voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | EPP | Against |
| Johan VAN OVERTVELDT | Belgium | ECR | Against |
| Jonás FERNÁNDEZ | Spain | S&D | For |
| Jordan BARDELLA | France | Patriots | Against |
| Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA | Spain | Patriots | Against |
| Jörgen WARBORN voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | EPP | Against |
| Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR | Spain | S&D | For |
| Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ | Spain | EPP | For |
| Jutta PAULUS | Germany | Greens | For |
| Karin KARLSBRO | Sweden | Renew | For |
| Karlo RESSLER | Croatia | EPP | For |
| Kateřina KONEČNÁ | Czechia | No group | For |
| Kathleen VAN BREMPT | Belgium | S&D | For |
| Katrin LANGENSIEPEN | Germany | Greens | For |
| Konstantinos ARVANITIS voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Greece | The Left | Against |
| Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Kostas PAPADAKIS | Greece | No group | Abstained |
| Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA | Spain | S&D | For |
| Laurence FARRENG | France | Renew | For |
| Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS | Greece | No group | Abstained |
| Leila CHAIBI | France | The Left | For |
| Lídia PEREIRA | Portugal | EPP | For |
| Lina GÁLVEZ | Spain | S&D | For |
| Liudas MAŽYLIS | Lithuania | EPP | For |
| Loránt VINCZE voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Romania | EPP | Against |
| Loucas FOURLAS | Cyprus | EPP | For |
| Luděk NIEDERMAYER | Czechia | EPP | For |
| Lukas MANDL | Austria | EPP | For |
| Łukasz KOHUT | Poland | EPP | For |
| Luke Ming FLANAGAN | Ireland | The Left | For |
| Magdalena ADAMOWICZ | Poland | EPP | For |
| Manfred WEBER | Germany | EPP | For |
| Manon AUBRY | France | The Left | For |
| Manuela RIPA | Germany | EPP | For |
| Marc ANGEL | Luxembourg | S&D | For |
| Marc BOTENGA | Belgium | The Left | For |
| Marcos ROS SEMPERE | Spain | S&D | For |
| Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN | Spain | Patriots | Against |
| Maria GRAPINI | Romania | S&D | For |
| Maria NOICHL | Germany | S&D | For |
| Maria WALSH | Ireland | EPP | For |
| Marianne VIND voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Denmark | S&D | Against |
| Marie DAUCHY | France | Patriots | Against |
| Marie TOUSSAINT | France | Greens | For |
| Marina KALJURAND | Estonia | S&D | For |
| Marina MESURE | France | The Left | For |
| Mario FURORE | Italy | The Left | For |
| Marion WALSMANN | Germany | EPP | For |
| Markéta GREGOROVÁ | Czechia | Greens | For |
| Markus BUCHHEIT | Germany | ESN | Against |
| Markus FERBER | Germany | EPP | For |
| Martin HÄUSLING | Germany | Greens | For |
| Martin HOJSÍK | Slovakia | Renew | For |
| Martin SCHIRDEWAN | Germany | The Left | For |
| Martin SONNEBORN | Germany | No group | For |
| Martine KEMP | Luxembourg | EPP | For |
| Massimiliano SALINI | Italy | EPP | For |
| Mathilde ANDROUËT | France | Patriots | Against |
| Matjaž NEMEC | Slovenia | S&D | For |
| Matthias ECKE | Germany | S&D | For |
| Michael GAHLER voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Germany | EPP | Against |
| Michal WIEZIK | Slovakia | Renew | For |
| Mihai TUDOSE | Romania | S&D | For |
| Milan UHRÍK | Slovakia | ESN | Against |
| Milan ZVER voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Slovenia | EPP | Against |
| Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA | Romania | EPP | For |
| Miriam LEXMANN voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Slovakia | EPP | Against |
| Mohammed CHAHIM | Netherlands | S&D | For |
| Monika HOHLMEIER | Germany | EPP | For |
| Moritz KÖRNER | Germany | Renew | For |
| Mounir SATOURI | France | Greens | For |
| Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR | Spain | S&D | For |
| Nadine MORANO voted otherwise than their group's clear line | France | EPP | Against |
| Nathalie LOISEAU | France | Renew | For |
| Niclas HERBST | Germany | EPP | For |
| Nicolas BAY voted otherwise than their group's clear line | France | ECR | For |
| Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES | Spain | S&D | For |
| Niels FUGLSANG voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Denmark | S&D | Against |
| Nikos PAPANDREOU | Greece | S&D | For |
| Nils UŠAKOVS | Latvia | S&D | For |
| Nora MEBAREK | France | S&D | For |
| Norbert LINS | Germany | EPP | For |
| Olivier CHASTEL | Belgium | Renew | For |
| Ondřej KNOTEK | Czechia | Patriots | Against |
| Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA | Spain | EPP | For |
| Paolo BORCHIA voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Italy | Patriots | Abstained |
| Pär HOLMGREN | Sweden | Greens | For |
| Pascal ARIMONT | Belgium | EPP | For |
| Pascal CANFIN | France | Renew | For |
| Patryk JAKI | Poland | ECR | Against |
| Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS | Lithuania | Renew | For |
| Philippe OLIVIER | France | Patriots | Against |
| Pietro FIOCCHI | Italy | ECR | Against |
| Pilar DEL CASTILLO VERA | Spain | EPP | For |
| Pina PICIERNO | Italy | Renew | For |
| Radan KANEV | Bulgaria | EPP | For |
| Raffaele STANCANELLI | Italy | Patriots | Against |
| Ralf SEEKATZ | Germany | EPP | For |
| Raphaël GLUCKSMANN | France | S&D | For |
| Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ | Lithuania | EPP | For |
| Rasmus ANDRESEN | Germany | Greens | For |
| René REPASI | Germany | S&D | For |
| Riho TERRAS voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Estonia | EPP | Against |
| Robert BIEDROŃ | Poland | S&D | For |
| Roman HAIDER | Austria | Patriots | Against |
| Romana TOMC | Slovenia | EPP | For |
| Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT | Spain | EPP | For |
| Sabine VERHEYEN | Germany | EPP | For |
| Salvatore DE MEO | Italy | EPP | For |
| Sandro GOZI | France | Renew | For |
| Sara MATTHIEU | Belgium | Greens | For |
| Saskia BRICMONT | Belgium | Greens | For |
| Seán KELLY voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Ireland | EPP | Against |
| Sergio BERLATO | Italy | ECR | Against |
| Siegfried MUREŞAN | Romania | EPP | For |
| Silvia SARDONE voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Italy | Patriots | Abstained |
| Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN | Finland | EPP | For |
| Stefan BERGER | Germany | EPP | For |
| Stéphanie YON-COURTIN | France | Renew | For |
| Sunčana GLAVAK | Croatia | EPP | For |
| Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ | Spain | EPP | For |
| Susanna CECCARDI voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Italy | Patriots | Abstained |
| Sven MIKSER | Estonia | S&D | For |
| Sven SIMON | Germany | EPP | For |
| Svenja HAHN | Germany | Renew | For |
| Tamás DEUTSCH | Hungary | Patriots | Against |
| Terry REINTKE | Germany | Greens | For |
| Thierry MARIANI | France | Patriots | Against |
| Thijs REUTEN | Netherlands | S&D | For |
| Thomas WAITZ | Austria | Greens | For |
| Tiemo WÖLKEN | Germany | S&D | For |
| Tilly METZ | Luxembourg | Greens | For |
| Tineke STRIK | Netherlands | Greens | For |
| Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Belgium | Patriots | For |
| Tomas TOBÉ voted otherwise than their group's clear line | Sweden | EPP | Against |
| Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ | Czechia | EPP | For |
| Tomislav SOKOL | Croatia | EPP | For |
| Tonino PICULA | Croatia | S&D | For |
| Tsvetelina PENKOVA | Bulgaria | S&D | For |
| Udo BULLMANN | Germany | S&D | For |
| Urmas PAET | Estonia | Renew | For |
| Valérie HAYER | France | Renew | For |
| Vangelis MEIMARAKIS | Greece | EPP | For |
| Veronika VRECIONOVÁ | Czechia | ECR | Against |
| Victor NEGRESCU | Romania | S&D | For |
| Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ | Lithuania | S&D | For |
| Ville NIINISTÖ | Finland | Greens | For |
| Virginie JORON | France | Patriots | Against |
| Waldemar TOMASZEWSKI | Lithuania | ECR | Against |
| Željana ZOVKO | Croatia | EPP | For |
No vote recorded
Members in office that day without a recorded position. No vote recorded is not the same as absent: leave, illness or chairing the sitting look the same.
The list of members without a recorded position is not available right now.
Similar votes
Roll calls that split the chamber the most similarly: r is the correlation of members’ positions, over the members who voted in both. Other votes on the same decision are left out.
Similar votes are not available right now.
Compare with another vote
Groups’ lines side by side, and the members who switched between the two votes.
Connections
This vote’s decision, the other votes on it, and related votes.
No connections found for this vote.
Sources & citation
Where the facts on this page come from, and how to cite it.
- Official sources
- Data source
- Licensed CC BY 4.0.
- Retrieved
- 25 September 2026
Cite as
European Parliament (2023). “Separate vote: paragraph 5”. Vote, 22 November 2023. votingId 161594. EU Parl Watch Research. https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2023-11-22/161594 (retrieved 25 September 2026). Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 22 November 2023 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-22-RCV_EN.html; Results of votes, sitting of 22 November 2023 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-22-VOT_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2023-11-22, https://data.europarl.europa.eu/api/v2/meetings/MTG-PL-2023-11-22/vote-results?format=application%2Fld%2Bjson (CC BY 4.0).
BibTeX
@misc{epw-vote-2023-11-22-161594,
author = {{European Parliament}},
title = {{Separate vote: paragraph 5}},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-11-22},
howpublished = {\url{https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2023-11-22/161594}},
url = {https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/votes/2023-11-22/161594},
urldate = {2026-09-25},
publisher = {EU Parl Watch Research},
note = {Vote. votingId 161594. Official source: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-22-RCV\_EN.html, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-22-VOT\_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: vote results of the sitting MTG-PL-2023-11-22 (CC BY 4.0)}
}