Decision · Objection under Rule 115(2) and (3) · implementing measure

Genetically modified soybean MON 87705 × MON 87708 × MON 89788

Effect: Objection passed
Result: 373 for · 150 against · 10 abstained roll call
Date: 8 May 2025, 13:51
Kind: Objection to a Commission measure

More facts (10)

Margin: by a large majority
Counts are for: the objection
Text: Motion B-10-2025-0244
Dossier: 2025/2647(RSP)
Source: Motion for a resolution
Topics: Agriculture, food & fisheries Assigned by a model, not checked by hand.
Votes: 1 vote · 1 roll call
Requested by: The Left (1 roll call)
Sitting: Thursday 8 May 2025
Final vote: 176089

Margin: by a large majority
Counts are for: the objection
Text: Motion B-10-2025-0244
Dossier: 2025/2647(RSP)
Source: Motion for a resolution
Topics: Agriculture, food & fisheries Assigned by a model, not checked by hand.
Votes: 1 vote · 1 roll call
Requested by: The Left (1 roll call)
Sitting: Thursday 8 May 2025
Final vote: 176089

Cite this page Roll-call results (EP)

Link to this page

Votes on this decision

Members on the final vote

Result

The final vote and what it means for this kind of decision.

Objection passed by a large majority.

The objection passed. For an implementing measure it is not legally binding: the Commission is asked to withdraw the measure but can still adopt it.

Backed by The Left, Greens, S&D, ECR, Patriots and ESN; opposed by Renew and EPP.

Groups

Members' votes, each counted in the group they belonged to on the day. **No vote**: in office that day, no position recorded. **Majority line**: the most common position. **Clear line**: a position with at least two thirds of the group's votes (at least 10 members voting), otherwise Divided. **Cohesion**: Agreement Index, 0 = evenly split, 1 = all voted the same (method).
Group	For	Against	Abst.	No vote	Majority line	Clear line	Cohesion
The Left	For 27	Against 0	Abst. 0	No vote 19 of 46	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 1.00
Greens	For 44	Against 0	Abst. 0	No vote 9 of 53	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 1.00
S&D	For 94	Against 1	Abst. 1	No vote 40 of 136	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 0.97
Renew	For 22	Against 34	Abst. 2	No vote 17 of 75	Majority line Against	Clear line Divided	Cohesion 0.38
EPP	For 39	Against 96	Abst. 2	No vote 51 of 188	Majority line Against	Clear line Against	Cohesion 0.55
ECR	For 47	Against 13	Abst. 2	No vote 18 of 80	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 0.64
Patriots	For 62	Against 6	Abst. 1	No vote 16 of 85	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 0.85
ESN	For 21	Against 0	Abst. 1	No vote 5 of 27	Majority line For	Clear line For	Cohesion 0.93
No group	For 17	Against 0	Abst. 1	No vote 11 of 29	Majority line —	Clear line No line	Cohesion —

Members who changed group are counted in the group of the day: Branko GRIMS changed group, Elena YONCHEVA changed group, Elisabetta GUALMINI changed group, Ewa ZAJĄCZKOWSKA-HERNIK changed group, Fernand KARTHEISER changed group, Jessika VAN LEEUWEN changed group, Laurent CASTILLO changed group, Lukas SIEPER changed group, Nikola BARTŮŠEK changed group, Nikolas FARANTOURIS changed group, Pina PICIERNO changed group, Roberto VANNACCI changed group, Sander SMIT changed group, Taner KABILOV changed group.

Voted against their group, 66

Members who voted otherwise than a clear line (at least two thirds of the votes cast, at least 10 members voting) of the group they sat in that day. A group without a clear line is divided and not counted.

S&D line For · 1 voted against, 1 abstained of 96 who voted
Voted against (1)
- Maria NOICHL Germany
Abstained (1)
- Vytenis Povilas ANDRIUKAITIS Lithuania
EPP line Against · 39 voted for, 2 abstained of 137 who voted
Voted for (39)
- Alexander BERNHUBER Austria
- András Tivadar KULJA Hungary
- Andrey KOVATCHEV Bulgaria
- Andrey NOVAKOV Bulgaria
- Andrzej HALICKI Poland
- Angelika WINZIG Austria
- Borys BUDKA Poland
- Christophe GOMART France
- Davor Ivo STIER Croatia
- Dóra DÁVID Hungary
- Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA Poland
- Eszter LAKOS Hungary
- Eva MAYDELL Bulgaria
- François-Xavier BELLAMY France
- Gabriella GERZSENYI Hungary
- Jagna MARCZUŁAJTIS-WALCZAK Poland
- Janusz LEWANDOWSKI Poland
- Karlo RESSLER Croatia
- Kinga KOLLÁR Hungary
- Krzysztof HETMAN Poland
- Laurent CASTILLO France
- Łukasz KOHUT Poland
- Manuela RIPA Germany
- Marta WCISŁO Poland
- Michał SZCZERBA Poland
- Michał WAWRYKIEWICZ Poland
- Miriam LEXMANN Slovakia
- Mirosława NYKIEL Poland
- Nadine MORANO France
- Pascal ARIMONT Belgium
- Péter MAGYAR Hungary
- Pilar DEL CASTILLO VERA Spain
- Reinhold LOPATKA Austria
- Romana TOMC Slovenia
- Sandra KALNIETE Latvia
- Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN Finland
- Sunčana GLAVAK Croatia
- Tomislav SOKOL Croatia
- Zala ČERNILEC TOMAŠIČ Slovenia
Abstained (2)
- Bogdan Andrzej ZDROJEWSKI Poland
- Isabel WISELER-LIMA Luxembourg
ECR line For · 13 voted against, 2 abstained of 62 who voted
Voted against (13)
- Alexandr VONDRA Czechia
- Beatrice TIMGREN Sweden
- Charlie WEIMERS Sweden
- Dick ERIXON Sweden
- Fernand KARTHEISER Luxembourg
- Francesco TORSELLI Italy
- Kris VAN DIJCK Belgium
- Kristoffer STORM Denmark
- Mariateresa VIVALDINI Italy
- Ondřej KRUTÍLEK Czechia
- Pietro FIOCCHI Italy
- Sebastian TYNKKYNEN Finland
- Veronika VRECIONOVÁ Czechia
Abstained (2)
- Diego SOLIER Spain
- Nora JUNCO GARCÍA Spain
Patriots line For · 6 voted against, 1 abstained of 69 who voted
Voted against (6)
- Hermann TERTSCH Spain
- Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA Spain
- Jorge MARTÍN FRÍAS Spain
- Juan Carlos GIRAUTA VIDAL Spain
- Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN Spain
- Mireia BORRÁS PABÓN Spain
Abstained (1)
- Filip TUREK Czechia
ESN line For · 1 abstained of 22 who voted
Abstained (1)
- Volker SCHNURRBUSCH Germany

Countries

The final vote by national delegation.

Votes by country (27 delegations)

Members' votes by country. **No vote**: in office that day, no position recorded. **Cohesion**: Agreement Index of the delegation, 0 = evenly split, 1 = all the same; it reflects the mix of groups (method).
Country	For	Against	Abst.	No vote	Cohesion
Austria	16	1	0	3	0.91
Belgium	9	6	0	7	0.40
Bulgaria	11	1	0	5	0.88
Cyprus	2	1	0	3	—
Czechia	11	7	1	2	0.37
Germany	46	28	1	21	0.42
Denmark	6	5	0	4	0.32
Estonia	3	3	0	1	—
Spain	17	19	2	22	0.25
Finland	7	3	0	5	0.55
France	60	1	1	19	0.95
Greece	9	0	0	12	—
Croatia	9	0	0	3	—
Hungary	11	0	0	10	1.00
Ireland	5	8	0	1	0.42
Italy	42	11	0	23	0.69
Lithuania	4	2	1	4	—
Luxembourg	2	2	1	1	—
Latvia	6	1	0	2	—
Malta	3	2	0	1	—
Netherlands	17	13	0	1	0.35
Poland	34	9	2	8	0.63
Portugal	9	5	1	6	0.40
Romania	15	11	0	7	0.37
Sweden	10	11	0	0	0.29
Slovenia	5	0	0	4	—
Slovakia	4	0	0	11	—

Members

Each member’s recorded position on the final roll call, in the group they sat in that day. Filter by country, group, position or name.

533 members with a recorded position.

Each member's recorded position. **≠ group**: voted otherwise than a clear line (at least two thirds) of their group.
Member	Country	Group	Position
Abir AL-SAHLANI	Sweden	Renew	Against
Adam BIELAN	Poland	ECR	For
Adam JARUBAS	Poland	EPP	Against
Adina VĂLEAN	Romania	EPP	Against
Adnan DIBRANI	Sweden	S&D	For
Adrian-George AXINIA	Romania	ECR	For
Alberico GAMBINO	Italy	ECR	For
Aldo PATRICIELLO	Italy	Patriots	For
Aleksandar NIKOLIC	France	Patriots	For
Alessandro CIRIANI	Italy	ECR	For
Alex AGIUS SALIBA	Malta	S&D	For
Alexander BERNHUBER voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Austria	EPP	For
Alexander JUNGBLUTH	Germany	ESN	For
Alexander SELL	Germany	ESN	For
Alexandr VONDRA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Czechia	ECR	Against
Alexandra GEESE	Germany	Greens	For
Alexandra MEHNERT	Germany	EPP	Against
Alexandre VARAUT	France	Patriots	For
Alice KUHNKE	Sweden	Greens	For
Alice TEODORESCU MÅWE	Sweden	EPP	Against
Alicia HOMS GINEL	Spain	S&D	For
Ana Catarina MENDES	Portugal	S&D	For
Ana MIRANDA PAZ	Spain	Greens	For
Ana VASCONCELOS	Portugal	Renew	For
Anders VISTISEN	Denmark	Patriots	For
Andi CRISTEA	Romania	S&D	For
András LÁSZLÓ	Hungary	Patriots	For
András Tivadar KULJA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Hungary	EPP	For
André ROUGÉ	France	Patriots	For
Andrea WECHSLER	Germany	EPP	Against
Andreas GLÜCK	Germany	Renew	Against
Andreas SCHIEDER	Austria	S&D	For
Andreas SCHWAB	Germany	EPP	Against
Andrey KOVATCHEV voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Bulgaria	EPP	For
Andrey NOVAKOV voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Bulgaria	EPP	For
Andrzej BUŁA	Poland	EPP	Against
Andrzej HALICKI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Angelika NIEBLER	Germany	EPP	Against
Angelika WINZIG voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Austria	EPP	For
Angéline FURET	France	Patriots	For
Anja ARNDT	Germany	ESN	For
Anna BRYŁKA	Poland	Patriots	For
Anna CAVAZZINI	Germany	Greens	For
Anna STROLENBERG	Netherlands	Greens	For
Anna STÜRGKH	Austria	Renew	Against
Anna ZALEWSKA	Poland	ECR	For
Anna-Maja HENRIKSSON	Finland	Renew	Against
Annalisa CORRADO	Italy	S&D	For
Annamária VICSEK	Hungary	Patriots	For
Anne-Sophie FRIGOUT	France	Patriots	For
Anouk VAN BRUG	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Anthony SMITH	France	The Left	For
Antonella SBERNA	Italy	ECR	For
Antonio DECARO	Italy	S&D	For
António TÂNGER CORRÊA	Portugal	Patriots	For
Aodhán Ó RÍORDÁIN	Ireland	S&D	For
Arash SAEIDI	France	The Left	For
Arba KOKALARI	Sweden	EPP	Against
Arkadiusz MULARCZYK	Poland	ECR	For
Auke ZIJLSTRA	Netherlands	Patriots	For
Aurelijus VERYGA	Lithuania	ECR	For
Barry ANDREWS	Ireland	Renew	Against
Barry COWEN	Ireland	Renew	Against
Bart GROOTHUIS	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Bartłomiej SIENKIEWICZ	Poland	EPP	Against
Bartosz ARŁUKOWICZ	Poland	EPP	Against
Bas EICKHOUT	Netherlands	Greens	For
Beata SZYDŁO	Poland	ECR	For
Beatrice TIMGREN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Sweden	ECR	Against
Benedetta SCUDERI	Italy	Greens	For
Benoit CASSART	Belgium	Renew	Against
Bernd LANGE	Germany	S&D	For
Bert-Jan RUISSEN	Netherlands	ECR	For
Biljana BORZAN	Croatia	S&D	For
Billy KELLEHER	Ireland	Renew	For
Bogdan Andrzej ZDROJEWSKI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	Abstained
Bogdan RZOŃCA	Poland	ECR	For
Borja GIMÉNEZ LARRAZ	Spain	EPP	Against
Borys BUDKA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Brando BENIFEI	Italy	S&D	For
Brigitte VAN DEN BERG	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Bruno GONÇALVES	Portugal	S&D	For
Bruno TOBBACK	Belgium	S&D	For
Camilla LAURETI	Italy	S&D	For
Carla TAVARES	Portugal	S&D	For
Carlo FIDANZA	Italy	ECR	For
Carmen CRESPO DÍAZ	Spain	EPP	Against
Catarina VIEIRA	Netherlands	Greens	For
Caterina CHINNICI	Italy	EPP	Against
Catherine GRISET	France	Patriots	For
Cecilia STRADA	Italy	S&D	For
César LUENA	Spain	S&D	For
Charles GOERENS	Luxembourg	Renew	Against
Charlie WEIMERS voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Sweden	ECR	Against
Christel SCHALDEMOSE	Denmark	S&D	For
Christian DOLESCHAL	Germany	EPP	Against
Christine ANDERSON	Germany	ESN	For
Christine SCHNEIDER	Germany	EPP	Against
Christophe BAY	France	Patriots	For
Christophe CLERGEAU	France	S&D	For
Christophe GOMART voted otherwise than their group's clear line	France	EPP	For
Christophe GRUDLER	France	Renew	For
Ciaran MULLOOLY	Ireland	Renew	Against
Claire FITA	France	S&D	For
Claudiu-Richard TÂRZIU	Romania	ECR	For
Cristian TERHEŞ	Romania	ECR	For
Cristina MAESTRE	Spain	S&D	For
Csaba DÖMÖTÖR	Hungary	Patriots	For
Cynthia NÍ MHURCHÚ	Ireland	Renew	Against
Damian BOESELAGER	Germany	Greens	For
Dan BARNA	Romania	Renew	Against
Dan-Ştefan MOTREANU	Romania	EPP	Against
Daniel ATTARD	Malta	S&D	For
Daniel BUDA	Romania	EPP	Against
Daniel CASPARY	Germany	EPP	Against
Daniel FREUND	Germany	Greens	For
Daniele POLATO	Italy	ECR	For
Danilo DELLA VALLE	Italy	The Left	For
Dario TAMBURRANO	Italy	The Left	For
Dariusz JOŃSKI	Poland	EPP	Against
David CASA	Malta	EPP	Against
David CORMAND	France	Greens	For
Davor Ivo STIER voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Croatia	EPP	For
Delara BURKHARDT	Germany	S&D	For
Denis NESCI	Italy	ECR	For
Dennis RADTKE	Germany	EPP	Against
Diana IOVANOVICI ŞOŞOACĂ	Romania	No group	For
Diana RIBA I GINER	Spain	Greens	For
Dick ERIXON voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Sweden	ECR	Against
Diego SOLIER voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	ECR	Abstained
Dirk GOTINK	Netherlands	EPP	Against
Dolors MONTSERRAT	Spain	EPP	Against
Dóra DÁVID voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Hungary	EPP	For
Dragoş BENEA	Romania	S&D	For
Eero HEINÄLUOMA	Finland	S&D	For
Elena NEVADO DEL CAMPO	Spain	EPP	Against
Elena SANCHO MURILLO	Spain	S&D	For
Elio DI RUPO	Belgium	S&D	For
Elisabeth DIERINGER	Austria	Patriots	For
Elisabeth GROSSMANN	Austria	S&D	For
Elsi KATAINEN	Finland	Renew	For
Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Emma FOURREAU	France	The Left	For
Emma WIESNER	Sweden	Renew	Against
Emmanouil FRAGKOS	Greece	ECR	For
Engin EROGLU	Germany	Renew	Against
Enikő GYŐRI	Hungary	Patriots	For
Erik MARQUARDT	Germany	Greens	For
Esteban GONZÁLEZ PONS	Spain	EPP	Against
Estelle CEULEMANS	Belgium	S&D	For
Estrella GALÁN	Spain	The Left	For
Eszter LAKOS voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Hungary	EPP	For
Eva MAYDELL voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Bulgaria	EPP	For
Evelyn REGNER	Austria	S&D	For
Evin INCIR	Sweden	S&D	For
Ewa KOPACZ	Poland	EPP	Against
Fabienne KELLER	France	Renew	For
Fabio DE MASI	Germany	No group	For
Fabrice LEGGERI	France	Patriots	For
Fernand KARTHEISER voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Luxembourg	ECR	Against
Fernando NAVARRETE ROJAS	Spain	EPP	Against
Fidias PANAYIOTOU	Cyprus	No group	For
Filip TUREK voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Czechia	Patriots	Abstained
Flavio TOSI	Italy	EPP	Against
France JAMET	France	Patriots	For
Francesco TORSELLI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Italy	ECR	Against
Francesco VENTOLA	Italy	ECR	For
Francisco ASSIS	Portugal	S&D	For
François KALFON	France	S&D	For
François-Xavier BELLAMY voted otherwise than their group's clear line	France	EPP	For
Friedrich PÜRNER	Germany	No group	For
Gabriele BISCHOFF	Germany	S&D	For
Gabriella GERZSENYI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Hungary	EPP	For
Galato ALEXANDRAKI	Greece	ECR	For
Geadis GEADI	Cyprus	ECR	For
Georg MAYER	Austria	Patriots	For
Georgiana TEODORESCU	Romania	ECR	For
Gerald HAUSER	Austria	Patriots	For
Gerben-Jan GERBRANDY	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Gheorghe CÂRCIU	Romania	S&D	For
Gheorghe FALCĂ	Romania	EPP	Against
Gheorghe PIPEREA	Romania	ECR	For
Gilles BOYER	France	Renew	For
Giorgio GORI	Italy	S&D	For
Giovanni CROSETTO	Italy	ECR	For
Giuseppe ANTOCI	Italy	The Left	For
Giuseppe LUPO	Italy	S&D	For
Giusi PRINCI	Italy	EPP	Against
Gordan BOSANAC	Croatia	Greens	For
Grégory ALLIONE	France	Renew	For
Günther SIDL	Austria	S&D	For
Hanna GEDIN	Sweden	The Left	For
Hanna GRONKIEWICZ-WALTZ	Poland	EPP	Against
Hannes HEIDE	Austria	S&D	For
Hans NEUHOFF	Germany	ESN	For
Harald VILIMSKY	Austria	Patriots	For
Hélder SOUSA SILVA	Portugal	EPP	Against
Heléne FRITZON	Sweden	S&D	For
Henrik DAHL	Denmark	EPP	Against
Herbert DORFMANN	Italy	EPP	Against
Hermann TERTSCH voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	Patriots	Against
Hilde VAUTMANS	Belgium	Renew	Against
Hristo PETROV	Bulgaria	Renew	For
Ilaria SALIS	Italy	The Left	For
Ilhan KYUCHYUK	Bulgaria	Renew	For
Inese VAIDERE	Latvia	EPP	Against
Ingeborg TER LAAK	Netherlands	EPP	Against
Ioan-Rareş BOGDAN	Romania	EPP	Against
Irena JOVEVA	Slovenia	Renew	For
Irene TINAGLI	Italy	S&D	For
Irmhild BOSSDORF	Germany	ESN	For
Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA	Spain	EPP	Against
Isabel WISELER-LIMA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Luxembourg	EPP	Abstained
Isabella LÖVIN	Sweden	Greens	For
Isabella TOVAGLIERI	Italy	Patriots	For
Isilda GOMES	Portugal	S&D	For
Iuliu WINKLER	Romania	EPP	Against
Ivan DAVID	Czechia	ESN	For
Jacek OZDOBA	Poland	ECR	For
Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA	Poland	ECR	For
Jagna MARCZUŁAJTIS-WALCZAK voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Jan FARSKÝ	Czechia	EPP	Against
Jan-Christoph OETJEN	Germany	Renew	Against
Jan-Peter WARNKE	Germany	No group	For
Jana NAGYOVÁ	Czechia	Patriots	For
Jana TOOM	Estonia	Renew	For
Janusz LEWANDOWSKI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Jaroslav BŽOCH	Czechia	Patriots	For
Jaroslava POKORNÁ JERMANOVÁ	Czechia	Patriots	For
Javier ZARZALEJOS	Spain	EPP	Against
Jean-Marc GERMAIN	France	S&D	For
Jean-Paul GARRAUD	France	Patriots	For
Jeannette BALJEU	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Jens GEIER	Germany	S&D	For
Jens GIESEKE	Germany	EPP	Against
Jeroen LENAERS	Netherlands	EPP	Against
Jessica POLFJÄRD	Sweden	EPP	Against
Jessika VAN LEEUWEN	Netherlands	EPP	Against
Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI	Poland	ECR	For
Joachim STREIT	Germany	Renew	Against
Joanna SCHEURING-WIELGUS	Poland	S&D	For
João COTRIM DE FIGUEIREDO	Portugal	Renew	Abstained
João OLIVEIRA	Portugal	The Left	For
Johan DANIELSSON	Sweden	S&D	For
Jonás FERNÁNDEZ	Spain	S&D	For
Jonas SJÖSTEDT	Sweden	The Left	For
Jordan BARDELLA	France	Patriots	For
Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	Patriots	Against
Jorge MARTÍN FRÍAS voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	Patriots	Against
Jörgen WARBORN	Sweden	EPP	Against
José CEPEDA	Spain	S&D	For
Juan Carlos GIRAUTA VIDAL voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	Patriots	Against
Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR	Spain	S&D	For
Julie RECHAGNEUX	France	Patriots	For
Julien SANCHEZ	France	Patriots	For
Jüri RATAS	Estonia	EPP	Against
Jussi SARAMO	Finland	The Left	For
Jutta PAULUS	Germany	Greens	For
Kai TEGETHOFF	Germany	Greens	For
Kamila GASIUK-PIHOWICZ	Poland	EPP	Against
Karin KARLSBRO	Sweden	Renew	Against
Karlo RESSLER voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Croatia	EPP	For
Kateřina KONEČNÁ	Czechia	No group	For
Kathleen FUNCHION	Ireland	The Left	For
Kathleen VAN BREMPT	Belgium	S&D	For
Katri KULMUNI	Finland	Renew	Against
Katrin LANGENSIEPEN	Germany	Greens	For
Kim VAN SPARRENTAK	Netherlands	Greens	For
Kinga KOLLÁR voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Hungary	EPP	For
Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN	Denmark	Greens	For
Klara DOSTALOVA	Czechia	Patriots	For
Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI	Poland	ECR	For
Kostas PAPADAKIS	Greece	No group	For
Kris VAN DIJCK voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Belgium	ECR	Against
Kristian VIGENIN	Bulgaria	S&D	For
Kristoffer STORM voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Denmark	ECR	Against
Krzysztof HETMAN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Krzysztof ŚMISZEK	Poland	S&D	For
Lara WOLTERS	Netherlands	S&D	For
Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA	Spain	S&D	For
Laurence TROCHU	France	ECR	For
Laurent CASTILLO voted otherwise than their group's clear line	France	EPP	For
Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS	Greece	No group	For
Leila CHAIBI	France	The Left	For
Leire PAJÍN	Spain	S&D	For
Lena SCHILLING	Austria	Greens	For
Leoluca ORLANDO	Italy	Greens	For
Letizia MORATTI	Italy	EPP	Against
Li ANDERSSON	Finland	The Left	For
Liesbet SOMMEN	Belgium	EPP	Against
Liudas MAŽYLIS	Lithuania	EPP	Against
Loránt VINCZE	Romania	EPP	Against
Luděk NIEDERMAYER	Czechia	EPP	Against
Ľudovít ÓDOR	Slovakia	Renew	For
Lukas SIEPER	Germany	No group	For
Łukasz KOHUT voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Lynn BOYLAN	Ireland	The Left	For
Maciej WĄSIK	Poland	ECR	For
Magdalena ADAMOWICZ	Poland	EPP	Against
Majdouline SBAI	France	Greens	For
Małgorzata GOSIEWSKA	Poland	ECR	For
Malik AZMANI	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Malika SOREL	France	No group	Abstained
Manon AUBRY	France	The Left	For
Manuela RIPA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Germany	EPP	For
Maravillas ABADÍA JOVER	Spain	EPP	Against
Marc ANGEL	Luxembourg	S&D	For
Marc BOTENGA	Belgium	The Left	For
Marc JONGEN	Germany	ESN	For
Marcin SYPNIEWSKI	Poland	ESN	For
Marco FALCONE	Italy	EPP	Against
Marco TARQUINIO	Italy	S&D	For
Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	Patriots	Against
Maria NOICHL voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Germany	S&D	Against
Maria OHISALO	Finland	Greens	For
Maria WALSH	Ireland	EPP	Against
Maria ZACHARIA	Greece	No group	For
Mariateresa VIVALDINI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Italy	ECR	Against
Marie TOUSSAINT	France	Greens	For
Marie-Agnes STRACK-ZIMMERMANN	Germany	Renew	Against
Marie-Luce BRASIER-CLAIN	France	Patriots	For
Marie-Pierre VEDRENNE	France	Renew	For
Marieke EHLERS	Netherlands	Patriots	For
Marina KALJURAND	Estonia	S&D	For
Marina MESURE	France	The Left	For
Mario FURORE	Italy	The Left	For
Mario MANTOVANI	Italy	ECR	For
Marion MARÉCHAL	France	ECR	For
Marit MAIJ	Netherlands	S&D	For
Mariusz KAMIŃSKI	Poland	ECR	For
Markus BUCHHEIT	Germany	ESN	For
Markus FERBER	Germany	EPP	Against
Marlena MALĄG	Poland	ECR	For
Marta WCISŁO voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Martin HÄUSLING	Germany	Greens	For
Martin SCHIRDEWAN	Germany	The Left	For
Martin SONNEBORN	Germany	No group	For
Mārtiņš STAĶIS	Latvia	Greens	For
Mary KHAN	Germany	ESN	For
Massimiliano SALINI	Italy	EPP	Against
Mathilde ANDROUËT	France	Patriots	For
Matjaž NEMEC	Slovenia	S&D	For
Matteo RICCI	Italy	S&D	For
Matthias ECKE	Germany	S&D	For
Matthieu VALET	France	Patriots	For
Mélanie DISDIER	France	Patriots	For
Mélissa CAMARA	France	Greens	For
Michael BLOSS	Germany	Greens	For
Michael GAHLER	Germany	EPP	Against
Michael MCNAMARA	Ireland	Renew	For
Michael VON DER SCHULENBURG	Germany	No group	For
Michał DWORCZYK	Poland	ECR	For
Michał KOBOSKO	Poland	Renew	Abstained
Michał SZCZERBA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Michał WAWRYKIEWICZ voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Michalis HADJIPANTELA	Cyprus	EPP	Against
Mihai TUDOSE	Romania	S&D	For
Milan MAZUREK	Slovakia	ESN	For
Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA	Romania	EPP	Against
Mireia BORRÁS PABÓN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	Patriots	Against
Miriam LEXMANN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Slovakia	EPP	For
Mirosława NYKIEL voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Poland	EPP	For
Mohammed CHAHIM	Netherlands	S&D	For
Monika HOHLMEIER	Germany	EPP	Against
Moritz KÖRNER	Germany	Renew	Against
Morten LØKKEGAARD	Denmark	Renew	Against
Mounir SATOURI	France	Greens	For
Nadine MORANO voted otherwise than their group's clear line	France	EPP	For
Nela RIEHL	Germany	Greens	For
Niclas HERBST	Germany	EPP	Against
Nicola PROCACCINI	Italy	ECR	For
Nicola ZINGARETTI	Italy	S&D	For
Nicolas BAY	France	ECR	For
Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES	Spain	S&D	For
Nicolás PASCUAL DE LA PARTE	Spain	EPP	Against
Niels Flemming HANSEN	Denmark	EPP	Against
Niels FUGLSANG	Denmark	S&D	For
Niels GEUKING	Germany	EPP	Against
Nikola BARTŮŠEK	Czechia	Patriots	For
Nikola MINCHEV	Bulgaria	Renew	Against
Nikolaos ANADIOTIS	Greece	No group	For
Nikolas FARANTOURIS	Greece	The Left	For
Nikos PAPANDREOU	Greece	S&D	For
Nils UŠAKOVS	Latvia	S&D	For
Nina CARBERRY	Ireland	EPP	Against
Nora JUNCO GARCÍA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	ECR	Abstained
Norbert LINS	Germany	EPP	Against
Oihane AGIRREGOITIA MARTÍNEZ	Spain	Renew	For
Oliver SCHENK	Germany	EPP	Against
Olivier CHASTEL	Belgium	Renew	Against
Ondřej DOSTÁL	Czechia	No group	For
Ondřej KNOTEK	Czechia	Patriots	For
Ondřej KOLÁŘ	Czechia	EPP	Against
Ondřej KOVAŘÍK	Czechia	Patriots	For
Ondřej KRUTÍLEK voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Czechia	ECR	Against
Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA	Spain	EPP	Against
Paolo BORCHIA	Italy	Patriots	For
Paolo INSELVINI	Italy	ECR	For
Pär HOLMGREN	Sweden	Greens	For
Pascal ARIMONT voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Belgium	EPP	For
Pascal CANFIN	France	Renew	For
Pascale PIERA	France	Patriots	For
Pasquale TRIDICO	Italy	The Left	For
Patryk JAKI	Poland	ECR	For
Paulius SAUDARGAS	Lithuania	EPP	Against
Paulo CUNHA	Portugal	EPP	Against
Paulo DO NASCIMENTO CABRAL	Portugal	EPP	Against
Pernando BARRENA ARZA	Spain	The Left	For
Petar VOLGIN	Bulgaria	ESN	For
Peter AGIUS	Malta	EPP	Against
Peter LIESE	Germany	EPP	Against
Péter MAGYAR voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Hungary	EPP	For
Petr BYSTRON	Germany	ESN	For
Petra STEGER	Austria	Patriots	For
Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS	Lithuania	Renew	For
Philippe OLIVIER	France	Patriots	For
Pierfrancesco MARAN	Italy	S&D	For
Pierre JOUVET	France	S&D	For
Pierre PIMPIE	France	Patriots	For
Pierre-Romain THIONNET	France	Patriots	For
Pietro FIOCCHI voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Italy	ECR	Against
Pilar DEL CASTILLO VERA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Spain	EPP	For
Pina PICIERNO	Italy	S&D	For
Rachel BLOM	Netherlands	Patriots	For
Rada LAYKOVA	Bulgaria	ESN	For
Raffaele STANCANELLI	Italy	Patriots	For
Ralf SEEKATZ	Germany	EPP	Against
Raquel GARCÍA HERMIDA-VAN DER WALLE	Netherlands	Renew	Against
Rasmus ANDRESEN	Germany	Greens	For
Rasmus NORDQVIST	Denmark	Greens	For
Raúl DE LA HOZ QUINTANO	Spain	EPP	Against
Regina DOHERTY	Ireland	EPP	Against
Reinhold LOPATKA voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Austria	EPP	For
Reinier VAN LANSCHOT	Netherlands	Greens	For
Reinis POZŅAKS	Latvia	ECR	For
René AUST	Germany	ESN	For
René REPASI	Germany	S&D	For
Rihards KOLS	Latvia	ECR	For
Riho TERRAS	Estonia	EPP	Against
Robert BIEDROŃ	Poland	S&D	For
Roberto VANNACCI	Italy	Patriots	For
Roman HAIDER	Austria	Patriots	For
Romana JERKOVIĆ	Croatia	S&D	For
Romana TOMC voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Slovenia	EPP	For
Rudi KENNES	Belgium	The Left	For
Ruth FIRMENICH	Germany	No group	For
Sabrina REPP	Germany	S&D	For
Sakis ARNAOUTOGLOU	Greece	S&D	For
Salvatore DE MEO	Italy	EPP	Against
Sander SMIT	Netherlands	EPP	Against
Sandra GÓMEZ LÓPEZ	Spain	S&D	For
Sandra KALNIETE voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Latvia	EPP	For
Sandro GOZI	France	Renew	Against
Sandro RUOTOLO	Italy	S&D	For
Sarah KNAFO	France	ESN	For
Saskia BRICMONT	Belgium	Greens	For
Seán KELLY	Ireland	EPP	Against
Sebastiaan STÖTELER	Netherlands	Patriots	For
Sebastian KRUIS	Netherlands	Patriots	For
Sebastian TYNKKYNEN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Finland	ECR	Against
Sebastião BUGALHO	Portugal	EPP	Against
Şerban Dimitrie STURDZA	Romania	ECR	For
Sergio BERLATO	Italy	ECR	For
Sérgio HUMBERTO	Portugal	EPP	Against
Séverine WERBROUCK	France	Patriots	For
Siegbert Frank DROESE	Germany	ESN	For
Siegfried MUREŞAN	Romania	EPP	Against
Silvia SARDONE	Italy	Patriots	For
Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Finland	EPP	For
Sofie ERIKSSON	Sweden	S&D	For
Stanislav STOYANOV	Bulgaria	ESN	For
Stefan BERGER	Germany	EPP	Against
Stefan KÖHLER	Germany	EPP	Against
Ştefan MUŞOIU	Romania	S&D	For
Stefano CAVEDAGNA	Italy	ECR	For
Stéphanie YON-COURTIN	France	Renew	For
Stephen Nikola BARTULICA	Croatia	ECR	For
Stine BOSSE	Denmark	Renew	Against
Sunčana GLAVAK voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Croatia	EPP	For
Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ	Spain	EPP	Against
Sven MIKSER	Estonia	S&D	For
Svenja HAHN	Germany	Renew	Against
Taner KABILOV	Bulgaria	No group	For
Terry REINTKE	Germany	Greens	For
Thierry MARIANI	France	Patriots	For
Thijs REUTEN	Netherlands	S&D	For
Thomas BAJADA	Malta	S&D	For
Thomas GEISEL	Germany	No group	For
Thomas PELLERIN-CARLIN	France	S&D	For
Thomas WAITZ	Austria	Greens	For
Tiago MOREIRA DE SÁ	Portugal	Patriots	For
Tilly METZ	Luxembourg	Greens	For
Tineke STRIK	Netherlands	Greens	For
Tobias CREMER	Germany	S&D	For
Tobiasz BOCHEŃSKI	Poland	ECR	For
Tom BERENDSEN	Netherlands	EPP	Against
Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE	Belgium	Patriots	For
Tomáš KUBÍN	Czechia	Patriots	For
Tomas TOBÉ	Sweden	EPP	Against
Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ	Czechia	EPP	Against
Tomasz BUCZEK	Poland	Patriots	For
Tomasz FROELICH	Germany	ESN	For
Tomislav SOKOL voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Croatia	EPP	For
Ton DIEPEVEEN	Netherlands	Patriots	For
Tonino PICULA	Croatia	S&D	For
Tsvetelina PENKOVA	Bulgaria	S&D	For
Udo BULLMANN	Germany	S&D	For
Urmas PAET	Estonia	Renew	Against
Valentina PALMISANO	Italy	The Left	For
Valérie DELOGE	France	Patriots	For
Valérie DEVAUX	France	Renew	For
Valérie HAYER	France	Renew	For
Vasile DÎNCU	Romania	S&D	For
Veronika CIFROVÁ OSTRIHOŇOVÁ	Slovakia	Renew	For
Veronika VRECIONOVÁ voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Czechia	ECR	Against
Victor NEGRESCU	Romania	S&D	For
Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ	Lithuania	S&D	For
Vilis KRIŠTOPANS	Latvia	Patriots	For
Ville NIINISTÖ	Finland	Greens	For
Villy SØVNDAL	Denmark	Greens	For
Virgil-Daniel POPESCU	Romania	EPP	Against
Virginie JORON	France	Patriots	For
Virginijus SINKEVIČIUS	Lithuania	Greens	For
Vivien COSTANZO	Germany	S&D	For
Vlad VASILE-VOICULESCU	Romania	Renew	For
Vladimir PREBILIČ	Slovenia	Greens	For
Volker SCHNURRBUSCH voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Germany	ESN	Abstained
Vytenis Povilas ANDRIUKAITIS voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Lithuania	S&D	Abstained
Waldemar BUDA	Poland	ECR	For
Wouter BEKE	Belgium	EPP	Against
Younous OMARJEE	France	The Left	For
Zala ČERNILEC TOMAŠIČ voted otherwise than their group's clear line	Slovenia	EPP	For
Zsuzsanna BORVENDÉG	Hungary	ESN	For

Debate speakers and how they voted

Members who spoke in the plenary debate on the dossier. **Speeches**: how many times they took the floor. **Final vote**: their recorded position on this decision's final roll call.
Member	Group	Speeches	Spoke	Final vote
Javi LÓPEZ Spain	S&D	Speeches1	8 May 2025 (verbatim report, official site)	No vote recorded

All votes on this decision, 1

In voting order. **Result**: for–against–abstained (a show of hands has no count). **Requested by**: the groups that asked for a roll call, a split vote or a separate vote.
No.	Vote	Recorded	Result	Requested by
1	Final vote on the motion for a resolution B10-0244/2025 - Proposition de résolution	Roll call	373 for, 150 against, 10 abstained Adopted	Requested byroll call: The Left

Roll call requested by The Left.

Text

The text voted on.

Motion B-10-2025-0244

What this vote decides Written by AI from the official text — check the source

Parliament objected to a Commission draft decision that would authorise selling products made from genetically modified soybean MON 87705 × MON 87708 × MON 89788, which is tolerant to glyphosate and dicamba herbicides and has an altered fatty acid profile.

The objection was adopted, so the Commission measure is blocked and the soybean cannot be placed on the market in the EU.

Parliament cited concerns about the lack of a full assessment of the complementary herbicides and their effects on health and the environment.

Read the text · Report a problem

The text in short Written by AI from the official text — check the source

This resolution objects to the Commission's draft decision authorising the placing on the market of genetically modified soybean MON 87705 × MON 87708 × MON 89788. It considers the draft decision to exceed implementing powers and be inconsistent with Union law, and calls on the Commission to withdraw it.

Read the text · Report a problem

Dossier

Where the dossier stands and its other decisions in plenary.

2025/2647(RSP) · Resolution on a topical subject

Objection pursuant to Rule 115(2) and (3) of the Rules of Procedure to the draft Commission implementing Decision authorising the placing on the market of products containing, consisting of or produced from genetically modified soybean MON 87705 × MON 87708 × MON 89788 pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1829/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council

Parliament adopted the text on 8 May 2025. This is its final position on the matter.

Show the 3 steps of the dossier

Tabled for plenary (done)
Plenary vote · Adopted 8 May 2025 (done)
Parliament’s position · Final (done)

Lead committee: ENVI · Authors: Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN (EPP), Biljana BORZAN (S&D), Martin HÄUSLING (Greens), Anja HAZEKAMP (The Left)

Connections

What this decision touches: the procedural chain, the same text, running issues, votes that split the chamber the same way.

Show 6 connections: Other decisions of the part-session on ENVI dossiers · Final votes that split the chamber the same way

Other decisions of the part-session on ENVI dossiers

Decision The European Water Resilience Strategy Resolution · report by Thomas Bajada 7 May 2025 Adopted

See all

Final votes that split the chamber the same way

Decision Genetically modified oilseed rape MON 88302 Objection to a Commission measure · motion for a resolution 25 Nov 2025 Objection passed
Decision Genetically modified soybean MON 87708 Objection to a Commission measure · motion for a resolution 25 Nov 2025 Objection passed
Decision Genetically modified maize MON 87427 Objection to a Commission measure · motion for a resolution 25 Nov 2025 Objection passed
Decision Genetically modified maize DAS1131 Objection to a Commission measure · motion for a resolution 25 Nov 2025 Objection passed
Decision Genetically modified maize T25 (ACS-ZMØØ3-2) Objection to a Commission measure · motion for a resolution 11 Feb 2026 Objection passed

Sources & citation

Where the facts on this page come from, and how to cite it.

Permalink: https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-05-08/6?members=all
Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 8 May 2025 (European Parliament)
Results of votes, sitting of 8 May 2025 (European Parliament)
Data source: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2025-05-08
Licensed CC BY 4.0.
Retrieved: 25 September 2026

Cite as

European Parliament (2025). “Genetically modified soybean MON 87705 × MON 87708 × MON 89788”. Decision, 8 May 2025. votingId 176089, document B-10-2025-0244, reference 2025/2647(RSP). EU Parl Watch Research. https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-05-08/6?members=all (retrieved 25 September 2026). Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 8 May 2025 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-05-08-RCV_EN.html; Results of votes, sitting of 8 May 2025 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-05-08-VOT_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2025-05-08, https://data.europarl.europa.eu/api/v2/meetings/MTG-PL-2025-05-08/decisions?format=application%2Fld%2Bjson (CC BY 4.0).

BibTeX

@misc{epw-decision-2025-05-08-6,
  author = {{European Parliament}},
  title = {{Genetically modified soybean MON 87705 × MON 87708 × MON 89788}},
  year = {2025},
  date = {2025-05-08},
  howpublished = {\url{https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-05-08/6?members=all}},
  url = {https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2025-05-08/6?members=all},
  urldate = {2026-09-25},
  publisher = {EU Parl Watch Research},
  note = {Decision. votingId 176089, document B-10-2025-0244, reference 2025/2647(RSP). Official source: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-05-08-RCV\_EN.html, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2025-05-08-VOT\_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2025-05-08 (CC BY 4.0)}
}