Skip to content

Decision

Null

Effect
No final vote
Result
192 for · 208 against · 26 abstained roll call
Date
8 November 2023, 15:57
Kind
Other decision
More facts (4)
Margin
narrowly
Votes
1 vote · 1 roll call
Final vote
160018
More

Result

The final vote and what it means for this kind of decision.

Final vote: 192 for, 208 against, 26 abstained (roll call).

No result recorded narrowly.

Backed by The Left, Greens and S&D; opposed by Renew, EPP, ECR, Patriots and ESN.

Groups

Members counted in their current group: the view with groups at the date of the vote is not available right now.

Members’ votes by their current group. Majority: the most common position. Clear line: a position with at least two thirds of the group’s votes, otherwise Divided.
GroupForAgainstAbst.Majority lineClear lineBar
The LeftFor 12Against 1Abst. 0Majority line ForClear line For
GreensFor 22Against 0Abst. 0Majority line ForClear line For
S&DFor 45Against 1Abst. 1Majority line ForClear line For
RenewFor 3Against 16Abst. 6Majority line AgainstClear line Divided
EPPFor 2Against 47Abst. 4Majority line AgainstClear line Against
ECRFor 1Against 13Abst. 0Majority line AgainstClear line Against
PatriotsFor 0Against 22Abst. 0Majority line AgainstClear line Against
ESNFor 0Against 1Abst. 0Majority line AgainstClear line Against
No groupFor 5Against 0Abst. 0Majority line ForClear line For

Voted against their group, 0

Members who voted otherwise than a clear line (at least two thirds of the votes cast) of their group — groups as of today: the view with groups at the date of the vote is not available right now.

Nobody voted against a clear line of their group.

Countries

The final vote by national delegation.

The breakdown by country is not available right now.

Members

Each member’s recorded position on the final roll call — groups as of today: the view with groups at the date of the vote is not available right now.

426 members with a recorded position.

Each member's recorded position. ≠ group: voted otherwise than a clear line (at least two thirds) of their group.
MemberCountryGroupPosition
Abir AL-SAHLANI SwedenRenew Against
Adam JARUBAS PolandEPP Against
Alessandra MORETTI ItalyS&D For
Alexander BERNHUBER AustriaEPP Against
Alexandr VONDRA CzechiaECR Against
Alexandra GEESE GermanyGreens For
Alice KUHNKE SwedenGreens For
Alicia HOMS GINEL SpainS&D For
Ana MIRANDA PAZ SpainGreens For
André ROUGÉ FrancePatriots Against
Andreas SCHIEDER AustriaS&D For
Andreas SCHWAB GermanyEPP Against
Andrey KOVATCHEV BulgariaEPP Against
Angelika WINZIG AustriaEPP Against
Anja HAZEKAMP NetherlandsThe Left For
Anna CAVAZZINI GermanyGreens For
Arba KOKALARI SwedenEPP Against
Assita KANKO BelgiumECR Against
Barry ANDREWS IrelandRenew Against
Bart GROOTHUIS NetherlandsRenew Against
Bernard GUETTA FranceRenew Against
Bert-Jan RUISSEN NetherlandsECR Against
Biljana BORZAN CroatiaS&D For
Brando BENIFEI ItalyS&D For
Carlo FIDANZA ItalyECR Against
Catherine GRISET FrancePatriots Against
César LUENA SpainS&D For
Charlie WEIMERS SwedenECR Against
Christel SCHALDEMOSE DenmarkS&D For
Christian DOLESCHAL GermanyEPP Against
Christophe CLERGEAU FranceS&D For
Christophe GRUDLER FranceRenew Against
Cristina MAESTRE SpainS&D For
Csaba MOLNÁR HungaryS&D For
Damian BOESELAGER GermanyGreens For
Damien CARÊME FranceThe Left For
Dan NICA RomaniaS&D For
Dan-Ştefan MOTREANU RomaniaEPP Against
Daniel BUDA RomaniaEPP Against
David CORMAND FranceGreens For
David MCALLISTER GermanyEPP Against
Delara BURKHARDT GermanyS&D For
Denis NESCI ItalyECR Against
Diana RIBA I GINER SpainGreens For
Dolors MONTSERRAT SpainEPP Against
Dragoş BENEA RomaniaS&D For
Eero HEINÄLUOMA FinlandS&D For
Elena KOUNTOURA GreeceThe Left For
Elena YONCHEVA voted otherwise than their group's clear line BulgariaECR For
Elisabetta GUALMINI ItalyRenew For
Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA voted otherwise than their group's clear line PolandEPP Abstained
Emma WIESNER SwedenRenew Against
Emmanouil KEFALOGIANNIS GreeceEPP Against
Engin EROGLU GermanyRenew Against
Enikő GYŐRI HungaryPatriots Against
Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS HungaryPatriots Against
Evelyn REGNER AustriaS&D For
Evin INCIR voted otherwise than their group's clear line SwedenS&D Abstained
Ewa KOPACZ PolandEPP Against
Fabienne KELLER FranceRenew Abstained
Former MEP #114268 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #118949 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124586 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124692 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124696 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124704 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #124705 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124708 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124709 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124710 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124712 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124714 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124734 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124738 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124739 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124771 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124777 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124780 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124781 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124812 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124821 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124844 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124856 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124872 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124873 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124875 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124891 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124929 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #124934 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124972 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124992 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #124996 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #125004 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #125021 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #125043 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #125045 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #125128 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #125214 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #125706 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #126644 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #127096 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #129164 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #130256 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #131507 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #134605 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #183338 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #185974 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #1892 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #189525 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #190518 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #190519 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #193273 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197415 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197418 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197419 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197422 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197431 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197436 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197437 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197441 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197446 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197452 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197457 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197458 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197459 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197467 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197472 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197478 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197480 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197482 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197483 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197489 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197496 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197502 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197508 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197511 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197512 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197513 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197515 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197522 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197526 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197527 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197530 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197531 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197540 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197544 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197546 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197547 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197548 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197550 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197566 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197567 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197571 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197584 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197585 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197587 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197588 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197608 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197611 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197616 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197619 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197626 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197631 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197634 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197635 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197638 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197641 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197645 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197650 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197654 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197657 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197668 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197680 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197692 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197698 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197717 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197720 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197728 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197731 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197742 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197743 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197767 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197771 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197785 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197787 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197788 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197791 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197792 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197799 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197806 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197808 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197817 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197827 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197828 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197835 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #197836 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197838 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197843 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197844 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197846 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #197848 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197849 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197868 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #197935 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #198096 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #198329 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #202351 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #202352 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #204334 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #204368 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #204416 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #204420 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #204443 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #204733 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #2054 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #205452 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #209140 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #218349 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #226260 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #228286 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #228604 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #229352 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #236052 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #23712 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #237320 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #23768 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #237779 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #238674 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #239255 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #239256 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #239257 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #239258 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #239271 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #240478 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #243912 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #243979 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #24505 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #245858 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #24594 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #247122 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #247709 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #247737 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #249284 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #249826 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #27714 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #28141 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #28161 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #28219 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #28288 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #28294 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #28340 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #28346 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #28353 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #28586 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #29579 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #33982 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #34578 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #35016 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #38398 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #38595 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #4344 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #4560 Former MEPs Abstained
Former MEP #58789 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #88715 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96646 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96648 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96713 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96725 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96734 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96739 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96743 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96747 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96771 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96772 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96820 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96829 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96867 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96868 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96885 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96891 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96922 Former MEPs Against
Former MEP #96952 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #96991 Former MEPs For
Former MEP #99283 Former MEPs Against
France JAMET FrancePatriots Against
Francisco José MILLÁN MON SpainEPP Against
François-Xavier BELLAMY FranceEPP Against
Gabriel MATO SpainEPP Against
Gabriele BISCHOFF GermanyS&D For
Gerolf ANNEMANS BelgiumPatriots Against
Gheorghe FALCĂ RomaniaEPP Against
Gilles BOYER FranceRenew Abstained
Giorgos GEORGIOU CyprusThe Left For
Günther SIDL AustriaS&D For
György HÖLVÉNYI HungaryPatriots Against
Hannes HEIDE AustriaS&D For
Heléne FRITZON SwedenS&D For
Herbert DORFMANN ItalyEPP Against
Hermann TERTSCH SpainPatriots Against
Hilde VAUTMANS BelgiumRenew Against
Ilhan KYUCHYUK BulgariaRenew Against
Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ SpainS&D For
Irena JOVEVA SloveniaRenew For
Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA SpainEPP Against
Isabel WISELER-LIMA LuxembourgEPP Against
Iuliu WINKLER RomaniaEPP Against
Jaak MADISON EstoniaECR Against
Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA PolandECR Against
Janusz LEWANDOWSKI PolandEPP Against
Javi LÓPEZ SpainS&D For
Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ SpainS&D For
Javier ZARZALEJOS SpainEPP Against
Jean-Paul GARRAUD FrancePatriots Against
Jens GEIER GermanyS&D For
Jens GIESEKE GermanyEPP Against
Jérémy DECERLE FranceRenew Against
Jeroen LENAERS NetherlandsEPP Against
Jonás FERNÁNDEZ SpainS&D For
Jordan BARDELLA FrancePatriots Against
Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA SpainPatriots Against
Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR SpainS&D For
Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ SpainEPP Against
Jutta PAULUS GermanyGreens For
Karin KARLSBRO SwedenRenew Against
Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ SlovakiaNo group For
Kateřina KONEČNÁ CzechiaNo group For
Kathleen VAN BREMPT BelgiumS&D For
Kim VAN SPARRENTAK NetherlandsGreens For
Kinga GÁL HungaryPatriots Against
Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN DenmarkGreens For
Klára DOBREV HungaryS&D For
Konstantinos ARVANITIS GreeceThe Left For
Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI PolandECR Against
Kostas PAPADAKIS GreeceNo group For
Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA SpainS&D For
Laurence FARRENG FranceRenew Abstained
Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS GreeceNo group For
Leila CHAIBI FranceThe Left For
Lídia PEREIRA PortugalEPP Against
Liudas MAŽYLIS LithuaniaEPP Against
Loránt VINCZE RomaniaEPP Against
Luděk NIEDERMAYER voted otherwise than their group's clear line CzechiaEPP Abstained
Lukas MANDL AustriaEPP Against
Luke Ming FLANAGAN IrelandThe Left For
Malik AZMANI NetherlandsRenew Against
Manfred WEBER GermanyEPP Against
Manon AUBRY FranceThe Left For
Manuela RIPA voted otherwise than their group's clear line GermanyEPP For
Marc ANGEL LuxembourgS&D For
Marc BOTENGA BelgiumThe Left For
Marcos ROS SEMPERE SpainS&D For
Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN SpainPatriots Against
Maria GRAPINI voted otherwise than their group's clear line RomaniaS&D Against
Marie DAUCHY FrancePatriots Against
Marie TOUSSAINT FranceGreens For
Marina MESURE FranceThe Left For
Mario FURORE ItalyThe Left For
Marion WALSMANN GermanyEPP Against
Markéta GREGOROVÁ CzechiaGreens For
Martin HOJSÍK SlovakiaRenew Abstained
Martine KEMP LuxembourgEPP Against
Mathilde ANDROUËT FrancePatriots Against
Michael BLOSS GermanyGreens For
Mihai TUDOSE RomaniaS&D For
Milan UHRÍK SlovakiaESN Against
Milan ZVER SloveniaEPP Against
Mohammed CHAHIM NetherlandsS&D For
Monika BEŇOVÁ SlovakiaNo group For
Morten LØKKEGAARD DenmarkRenew Against
Mounir SATOURI FranceGreens For
Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR SpainS&D For
Nathalie LOISEAU FranceRenew Abstained
Nicola PROCACCINI ItalyECR Against
Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES SpainS&D For
Niels FUGLSANG DenmarkS&D For
Nils UŠAKOVS LatviaS&D For
Nora MEBAREK FranceS&D For
Norbert LINS GermanyEPP Against
Ondřej KNOTEK CzechiaPatriots Against
Özlem DEMIREL GermanyThe Left For
Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA SpainEPP Against
Pär HOLMGREN SwedenGreens For
Pascal ARIMONT voted otherwise than their group's clear line BelgiumEPP Abstained
Peter LIESE GermanyEPP Against
Pietro FIOCCHI ItalyECR Against
Pina PICIERNO ItalyRenew For
Radan KANEV voted otherwise than their group's clear line BulgariaEPP For
Raffaele STANCANELLI ItalyPatriots Against
Raphaël GLUCKSMANN FranceS&D For
Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ LithuaniaEPP Against
Rasmus ANDRESEN GermanyGreens For
René REPASI GermanyS&D For
Robert BIEDROŃ PolandS&D For
Roberts ZĪLE LatviaECR Against
Romana TOMC SloveniaEPP Against
Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT SpainEPP Against
Sabine VERHEYEN GermanyEPP Against
Sandra KALNIETE LatviaEPP Against
Sandro GOZI FranceRenew Against
Sara MATTHIEU BelgiumGreens For
Saskia BRICMONT BelgiumGreens For
Seán KELLY IrelandEPP Against
Siegfried MUREŞAN RomaniaEPP Against
Stéphanie YON-COURTIN FranceRenew Abstained
Susanna CECCARDI ItalyPatriots Against
Sven MIKSER EstoniaS&D For
Svenja HAHN GermanyRenew Against
Tamás DEUTSCH HungaryPatriots Against
Terry REINTKE GermanyGreens For
Thierry MARIANI FrancePatriots Against
Thomas WAITZ AustriaGreens For
Tiemo WÖLKEN GermanyS&D For
Tineke STRIK NetherlandsGreens For
Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE BelgiumPatriots Against
Tomas TOBÉ SwedenEPP Against
Tomislav SOKOL voted otherwise than their group's clear line CroatiaEPP Abstained
Tsvetelina PENKOVA BulgariaS&D For
Valérie HAYER FranceRenew Against
Vangelis MEIMARAKIS GreeceEPP Against
Veronika VRECIONOVÁ CzechiaECR Against
Victor NEGRESCU RomaniaS&D For
Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ LithuaniaS&D For
Ville NIINISTÖ FinlandGreens For
Virginie JORON FrancePatriots Against
Younous OMARJEE voted otherwise than their group's clear line FranceThe Left Against
Željana ZOVKO CroatiaEPP Against

All votes on this decision, 1

In voting order. Result: for–against–abstained (a show of hands has no count). Requested by: the groups that asked for a roll call, a split vote or a separate vote.
No.VoteRecordedResultRequested by
1Ordre du jour de jeudi — Demande du groupe Verts/ALE — Thursday’s Agenda — Request from the Verts/ALE group — Tagesordnung für Donnerstag — Antrag der Verts/ALE-Fraktion Final vote Ordre du jour de jeudi - Demande du groupe Verts/ALE - Thursday’s Agenda - Request from the Verts/ALE group - Tagesordnung für Donnerstag - Antrag der Verts/ALE-Fraktion Roll call192 for, 208 against, 26 abstained

Text

The text voted on.

Parliament’s vote records link no text to this decision.

Connections

What this decision touches: the procedural chain, the same text, running issues, votes that split the chamber the same way.

No connections found for this decision.

Sources & citation

Where the facts on this page come from, and how to cite it.

Retrieved
25 September 2026

Cite as

European Parliament (2023). “Null”. Decision, 8 November 2023. votingId 160018. EU Parl Watch Research. https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2023-11-08/3?members=all (retrieved 25 September 2026). Official sources: Roll-call votes, sitting of 8 November 2023 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-08-RCV_EN.html; Results of votes, sitting of 8 November 2023 (European Parliament), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-08-VOT_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2023-11-08, https://data.europarl.europa.eu/api/v2/meetings/MTG-PL-2023-11-08/decisions?format=application%2Fld%2Bjson (CC BY 4.0).
BibTeX
@misc{epw-decision-2023-11-08-3,
  author = {{European Parliament}},
  title = {{Null}},
  year = {2023},
  date = {2023-11-08},
  howpublished = {\url{https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2023-11-08/3?members=all}},
  url = {https://news.eu-parl.st-solutions.dev/decisions/2023-11-08/3?members=all},
  urldate = {2026-09-25},
  publisher = {EU Parl Watch Research},
  note = {Decision. votingId 160018. Official source: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-08-RCV\_EN.html, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2023-11-08-VOT\_EN.html. Data: EP Open Data API: decisions of the sitting MTG-PL-2023-11-08 (CC BY 4.0)}
}